Trouble for Twitter: Zatko the whistleblower

By Isaac Williams

Twitter’s former security chief Pieter “Mudge” Zatko submitted a complaint to Congress last month. It highlighted many key flaws and “extreme, egregious deficiencies” in Twitter’s security, exposing a culture where the executive team preferred to hide problems from others instead of solving them.

Zatko was hired in November 2020 to improve Twitter’s security after a wave of high profile breaches. Such as, in August 2019 when CEO (at the time) Jack Dorsey’s twitter was hacked and posted messages supporting white supremacism. This was followed in July 2020 when a teenager compromised 45 high profile accounts (such as Elon Musk’s, Bill Gates’, and Barrack Obama’s) to post bitcoin scams that led to over $110,000 being stolen.

In an attempt to clean up their image, Twitter hired notable hacker and security expert Zatko to lead their security team. However, in January 2022, Twitter fired Zatko. Twitter later issued a statement saying it was assessing the impact of its “top priority work.”

Twitter has been known to have been infiltrated by foreign actors

After eight months of silence, the complaint sent to Congress was published. With Twitter already heavily in the limelight over Elon Musk’s attempted purchase, the complaint contained very strong allegations over the company’s security and how the executive team wanted to address it. Major points of complaint are that there have been several severe security lapses on the platform, and the executive team frequently misled government officials and its own board of directors about the security vulnerabilities in the platform. Twitter has been known to lie to government officials in the past: former CEO Jack Dorsey promised end to end encryption in 2018 to Senator Ron Wyden, and it has not been added to this day.

Another glaring fault highlighted in the report is the lack of restrictions on what user data can be accessed by Twitter’s own employees. This gives too many people access to too much of a user’s personal data. This is especially important as Twitter has been known to have been infiltrated by foreign actors, such as the Saudi Arabian spy who worked there between 2014 and 2015. It was also known that Indian Government officials also worked for Twitter and therefore had access to the data, but Twitter did nothing in response.

It is also stated that Twitter has violated a Federal Trade Commission (FTC) consent order which required the company to implement specific security protocols. After having recently paid $150 million to the FTC for using personal data for targeted ads without consent, a further potential fine is not a good look for Twitter.

It suggests that Twitter was happy to lie to its board, investors and Elon Musk’s team

The figures for the number of bots on Twitter also appear in the complaint. Zatko states Twitter knowingly downplays the level of bot activity on the platform and “deliberate ignorance was the norm” amongst the executive team. This is good news for Musk as he cites this as the main reason for trying to back out of the purchase agreement – arguing that the data on bot activity he was given in the contract was significantly underestimated. Musk jumped on this report and quickly issued a subpoena for Zatko to appear at the trial two weeks ago. He also shared a Washington Post article which suggested that the “spam prevalence” of bots was shared with the board but not the public. It suggests that Twitter was happy to lie to its board, investors and Elon Musk’s team – potentially demonstrating a high degree of truth to Musk’s claim that Twitter misled him during acquisition talks.

Twitter has hit back, arguing that the complaint is “riddled with inconsistencies and inaccuracies” and “appear[s] designed to capture attention and inflict harm on Twitter.” Twitter’s CEO also personally claimed Zatko’s complaints were a false narrative. However, Zatko’s record of being one of the most ethical and renowned security executives gives a strong degree of credibility to his account.

If Musk cannot use this information to help him back out of this purchase of Twitter, to his dismay, he will then be left with a company he believes has highly inflated user counts and has a vast array of security problems that will need to be urgently fixed.

Image: Cameron McAllister using OpenAI’s DALL-E 2