Trick or Treat? The Meaning of Halloween in Modern Britain

By Nathan Choat

Halloween is an oddity in the list of the UK’s annual festivities, celebrated by people across the
nation without us really knowing why. Has it got something to do with religion… maybe the devil? Nobody really knows. Plus, aside from children, nobody really seems to care: a quick survey of what my housemates think of Halloween resulted in answers ranging from “I have no real opinion” to “why are you even asking me that question?”

Nevertheless, figures show that Halloween is becoming more popular than ever, with shoppers
spending 82% more on the festival in 2018 than they did in 2013, just five years earlier. That’s
£419m spent on pumpkins, fancy dress and toffee apples. This curious tension between apathy and enthusiasm lies at the heart of our celebrations of Halloween and raises questions about the role and meaning of the festival in Britain today. (Spoiler: it’s not as black and white as you might think).

Believe it or not, Halloween is said to have originated from an ancient Celtic festival known as Samhain, which marked the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter. On the night of the 31 st October large bonfires were lit to ward off evil spirits, as the festival was said to symbolise the porous boundary between the world of the living and the world of the dead.

This information is interesting in itself – more interesting, dare I say, than re-watching The Nightmare Before Christmas for the thousandth time, or trying to decide what Halloween costume to wear this year. However, nobody knows about it because in recent years the festival has become nothing more than an opportunity for companies to take advantage of people’s curiosity for the supernatural and compel them to spend money on things that, frankly, they really don’t need.

Nowhere is this more the case than in America, where Halloween is not just a festival, it’s an industry. For one, the proportion of people that take part in Halloween in the states is much greater than here, at 81% compared to the UK’s 23%. Moreover, whereas each Brit will spend an average of £33 on Halloween every year, the typical American will shell out $74 – in total, Americans spend $9bn on the celebrations annually. Furthermore, multinational businesses play on people’s willingness to drop vast sums of money on Halloween by introducing special ‘spooky’ products, which recently just seems to involve dyeing food unusual colours. Phantom Frappuccino, anyone? How about a black burger…?

In the UK we might not quite have reached America’s level of Halloween mania, but we are certainly moving in that direction. Every year we never fail to spend more and more money on the holiday, dressing up in ever more ambitious costumes, decorating our houses in ever more intricate detail, and carving our pumpkins into ever more complicated designs (which, coincidentally, is an American import – originally people carved turnips).

Nevertheless, one question remains: why? If we don’t really care much about the true origins or meaning of Halloween, why do we allow ourselves to be so enchanted by its consumerist appeal? The answer lies in the fact that, ultimately, it is the very ambiguity of Halloween that makes it so endearing, as well as so easy to hijack for commercial gain. Besides its vague link to the supernatural, Halloween acts as a clean slate, a blank canvas onto which we can’t resist projecting our childlike terror of ghosts that go ‘boo!’ and monsters that lurk menacingly under our beds in the night. Aside from this, it is also a simple excuse to spend time with loved ones, celebrating a festival that isn’t burdened by the cultural and religious baggage of Christmas or Easter. To many, Halloween is the ultimate form of escapism.

So on the surface, Halloween is nothing more than a greedy cash-grab, and this perspective holds a lot of truth. However, it also means much more than that, never failing to grip people’s imaginations and evoke a shared, childish sense of creativity and wonder. No matter what you think of Halloween, this surely can’t be a bad thing.

Image by Open Grid Scheduler / Grid Engine via Flickr