Town vs gown: why can’t we share the dancefloor with locals?

By Ram Gupta
Coming from a town which I sincerely love, I am the first person to support pride of one’s birthplace. The area you spent your childhood, made your first friends and can always call home will naturally have a special spot in your heart. And when I return to my treasured town, part of me does shiver upon seeing something that’s changed; whether it be as small as a new doormat, or even bigger like a new building, it all feels a little strange. So when I hear or read about students ruining once idyllic cities and locals destroying students’ prized nightlife, my instant reaction isn’t one of indignation.
There’s no question Durham students have a reputation for coming from privileged backgrounds. And whether or not we deserve this label, the plethora of formals, wine and black tie balls that we are responsible for, don’t help to suppress it. A walk up the Bailey on most late nights will come with raucous college chants sang into your ears by a parade of intoxicated youths. It’s an odd enough experience when you’re a sober student seeing it, but for someone not linked to the University, it can be much worse.
That’s not to say we are the only ones who like a night out. Saturday nights are famously reserved for the locals. Dancing, drinks and döner kebabs are all shared indulgences. And according to cab drivers and college staff, they party just as hard, if not harder.
So why is there so much contempt for each other when it’s the other’s turn? Moreover, why do we even have to take turns? Why can’t we share the dancefloor, or go into any pub, club or takeaway we like without taking precautions?
The divide doesn’t stop at Durham nightlife. It’s ingrained into our day-to-day lives. The vast differences in political views, thoughts on municipal issues (river safety, for example) and even opinions of each other, all evidence deep-rooted disparities between these two parties. Pejorative, hurtful comments on the education, background and general qualities of the ‘opposing’ party have been heard being said from either side, highlighting real issues of prejudice.
So what specifically drives this hostility? Could it be that locals feel the tranquillity of Durham has been impaled by students? Have students exchanged Durham’s peace, beauty and simplicity for parties, University property and administrative procedures? Equally, are students exasperated by locals’ constant antagonising? Have the palpable attacks on innocent students gone too far?
Well, there’s no need to play the blame game; this invisible but very tangible line we have drawn between ourselves is neither party’s fault. It has come about because of basic cultural differences. Postcode, dialect and class; these dissimilarities have made us see each other as alien. That alienation has persisted and manipulated the way we continue to perceive each other. It has led to us seeing one another as unapproachable and has instilled a xenophobic fear into us, thus disinclining contact and interaction with each other, creating a vicious cycle that strengthens the partition. We don’t interact with each other because we feel we shouldn’t. The contrasts seen in one another are treated as causes for disfavour, exacerbating the animosity that pervades our sides.
I feel this alienation has stemmed from the parties’ initial shivers at change. They each might be trying to maintain their own ‘perfect’ image of the city. They might ‘shiver’ at the apparently negative changes the other party makes to preserve their seemingly discrepant Durham. But although students need roofs over their heads and locals deserve places to unwind, that doesn’t mean we can’t co-exist without damaging our ultimately very similar pictures of an ideal Durham; a Durham encompassed with co-operation, camaraderie and safety.
The problems lie in the imaginary line that’s been laid between two groups of people who actually have a lot in common while living in a small city. The solution: communication. There is a reason why we are more accepting of our own antics than others’ and that’s because we know the context that surrounds them (student culture, for example). If locals were given a place to voice their issues, through the Students’ Union for example, then the University could try to ameliorate them. If students and locals spoke more openly and honestly with each other, there may be less of a disdain for each other’s actions. The problems the two parties have with each other could be very simple misunderstandings that can be easily tackled. Without at least trying to find out, we will never know and the divide will only perpetuate. We should be partners, and perhaps with more communication and effort to interact, we can be.
Photographs: Jungpionier via Wikimedia Commons (Durham Castle); Adam Bruderer via Wikimedia Commons (Fighting Cocks)
