Tories turn to law and order: a return to more traditional politics?
By Max Minkin
Something happened last week that was in many ways a monumental occasion. It was not described as such in the press — nor did it grip the attention of commentators in the same way as the issue of foreign travel or vaccine passports. It was, nonetheless, very important.
After two years of ‘Get Brexit Done’ and ‘Stay at Home’, the Prime Minister, Boris Johnson, mentioned — on Tuesday last week — what might be described as a traditional political issue: that of crime or “law and order”. He talked of the need for criminals to pay back their debt to society through community service and to be seen doing so in “fluorescent-jacketed chain gangs”. Of course, Mr Johnson’s spokesman quickly clarified that no one would be chained, and that the essence of the government’s plans was to get offenders to do more unpaid work, especially cleaning up our streets, parks, and waterways.
Is this, in essence, a return to traditional politics?
This article will not debate the merits of this proposed policy. Instead, it will ask several more pertinent questions: why have the Tories decided to re-focus on law and order? Is Mr Johnson hoping to move the party away from the populism that propelled it into power and bring it back to a more small c- conservatism that appeals to the middle classes? Is this, in essence, a return to traditional politics?
To start, let us analyse the first question. Why, after two years of talking about Brexit and Covid-19 restrictions, have the Tories decided to bring up the issue of law and order? There are numerous explanations to choose from.
The most obvious one is that, as the pandemic comes to an end Mr Johnson and other senior ministers feel the need for them to start a new conversation, to create a new narrative to fill the airwaves and the papers before Sir Keir Starmer hijacks the political discourse and draws it towards the failures of the government. After all, every minute spent talking about fluorescent chain gangs is a minute not spent talking about Mr Johnson’s mismanagement of the pandemic.
When it comes to crime, Labour is hopeless.
The reason for picking law and order as the subject of this new political discourse is clear: when it comes to crime, Labour is hopeless. Despite Keir Starmer’s attempts to get “tough on crime”, his party suffers from a major philosophical obstacle that it is doomed never to overcome. Unlike the Tories — who believe that crime is the result of bad decisions by flawed individuals — Labour sees crime as merely a symptom of poverty, mental health issues and other social problems, something to pity rather than to clamp down on. For that reason, Labour could simply never be “tough on crime”, however much the voters wanted it from them.
Another explanation for the Tories shift to law and order might be the concerns raised by their defeat at the hands of the Liberal Democrats in recent Chesham and Amersham by-election. With Mr Johnson focussing on his agenda to “level up” the north, many traditional, middle-class Tories in the south-east could not help but feel abandoned by what had long been their party. One could quite conceivably argue that Mr Johnson’s renewed focus on ‘traditional’ concerns is the beginning of a move back to the small-c conservatism of earlier Tory leaders and away from the “northern-accented populism” that propelled the Conservative party into power in 2019.
So is this a short-term strategy for the government to fill in the news cycle and avoid scrutiny over its pandemic record? Or is it the beginning of a campaign to hold on to the core of middle-class Tory voters thinking of switching to the Liberal Democrats? All in all, it is too early to judge, and it could easily be both — only time will tell.
Image: UK Prime Minister via Creative Commons.

