Too early, too fast: the second year housing curse

By Juhi Sharma

If you have been at university for longer than a semester, you have probably heard of the Second Year Housing Curse: the phenomenon where the people you so excitedly sign a housing contract with in your first year end up being the ones you regret living with the most. What begins with, “We will be the best housemates ever!”, very quickly turns into loud noises at three am, a never-ending pile of dishes and numerous other frustrations.

For many first-year students, the idea of living independently is intoxicating. After months of shared dorm bedrooms and communal bathrooms, finally finding a house with friends feels like a rite of passage. You don’t just want anywhere to live; you want the right people to live with. Moreover, for most students, university marks the first time they have ever lived away from home. Before university, many of us lived in spaces where routines were managed by parents or guardians, and conflict was mediated by adults. Even in halls, this structure doesn’t disappear entirely. Cleaning staff, wardens and catered meals still create a safety net. But suddenly, in second year, you are expected to recreate a functioning household and instead of parents or siblings you are doing it with people you met only a few weeks ago at a random social or in your kitchen corridor.

The heart of the curse is that liking someone socially is not the same thing as being compatible housemates

There’s enormous pressure in the first year to sign a lease. There are bills to think about, limited availability and perhaps – especially in Durham – a housing market where there is scarce choice and decisions have to be made quickly. Most lease deadlines fall within the first month of the term, which is not enough time for many friendships to really develop beyond the casual social circles. I signed mine mid-October and unfortunately also fell victim to this curse.

The heart of the curse is that liking someone socially is not the same thing as being compatible housemates. In the first term, everyone is on their best behaviour. People are slightly performative as they make their first impressions. But living with someone reveals routines and rhythms that weren’t visible in the first few weeks. As someone who goes to sleep at 11 pm, I have had to learn the hard way that some people cook dinner at one am. The other frustrating part of a bad housing situation is the petty politics involved in things like cleaning rotas or rent payments. Many students have never managed bills, chores or schedules with peers before. Negotiating these responsibilities with people you barely know can feel awkward and exhausting. I remember the long messages in the group chat about housemates being too loud, not cleaning up after cooking, and not following the rota.

Despite knowing about the Second Year Curse, this pattern keeps repeating itself. Partly because of optimism bias, we want to believe we can make it work and assume communication can solve everything. I have heard horror stories from my friends in their respective second year housing, ranging from housemates not taking out the bins and others being downright disrespectful, entitled and racist. The sad truth is not everyone is compatible, no matter how friendly they seemed at first. It is really important for everyone to agree on basic rules of the house. Are dishes washed immediately? Is it okay to borrow food? Can you have friends over for parties or socials? Is the house cleaned weekly? These questions may be awkward to ask at first, but I have realised that avoiding them often leads to much greater discomfort later. 

The only way out of this is to give friendships more time before committing to a house. Learning how to coexist with others without mediation from adults is a skill that is learnt over time. I think the Second Year Curse is a rite of passage that teaches you the difficulty of transitioning from family life into full independence. It is ultimately a by-product of rushed decisions, evolving identities and the messy complexity of being a young adult with freedom for the first time. My experience taught me that I am better off living with people who have the same ideas of what a functioning house looks like. As I write this, in the warmth of my beautiful third year house, I could not be happier with my choice of housemates and, perhaps unexpectedly, a little grateful for everything second year taught me.

Image: W.carter via Wikimedia CommonsÂ