Tom Curry and rugby’s concussion problem

By Lizzie Hall

England concluded their Autumn Internationals with Sunday’s 59-14 home win against Japan. But Steve Borthwick’s controversial selection of Tom Curry has led to both fans and commentators questioning England Rugby’s effort to protect players against the life-long impacts of brain injuries. The Sale Shark flanker was knocked out only two weeks prior in an incidental collision during the Australia test match- this being his second concussion of the year. Was Curry’s quick return to play a responsible decision or does it suggest Rugby prioritises results over health?

Concussion is one of the most common injuries in rugby, where force to the head or body causes trauma to the brain which can result in long-term consequences if treatment is mismanaged. From repeated tackles during a player’s career, it is unsurprising that they are susceptible to head injuries. 

Concussion causes physical and behavioural changes such as nausea, memory loss, and loss of consciousness. It is crucial for players to be assessed and treated quickly after impact is they are suspected to have concussion, but with only 10% resulting in a loss of consciousness the signs are not always obvious. Additionally, unless an injured player seeks hospital treatment, they are unlikely to receive diagnosis. Therefore, protocols and awareness to prevent injured players from prematurely returning to rugby are vital. So, what is being done to protect the players? 

Unless an injured player seeks hospital treatment, they are unlikely to receive diagnosis

Recently elite rugby has undergone improvement and evolution in its guidelines to prevent the rate, impact, and reoccurrence of concussions from increasing. The 2009 sparked a seven-year period where the rate of concussion in the England professional men’s teams continued to grow until stabilising in 2016. 

This plateau came after the Head Injury Assessment Protocol was permanently introduced into World Rugby law in 2015, to improve the safety of elite adult rugby. This assessment includes screening for concussion both pitch side and throughout a player’s return to rugby. Independent Concussion Consultants were also introduced in 2015 for the Rugby World Cup, allowing asymptomatic injured players to undergo further testing before being cleared to play.

For the 2022-23 season, an updated graduated return to play protocol was introduced which prevents elite professional players from returning to match play within 12 days of confirmed concussion if they have a concussion history or were immediately removed from play for the duration of the match- both being the case for Curry. During match play of the same season, England senior men’s team saw concussion as the most common injury for the 12th successive season and as the highest burden injury for the 7th. This suggests that although the occurrence of concussion is not reducing, the current protocols are successful in improving diagnosis.

Curry’s selection for the Japan game was announced on the 13th day after his injury, with Borthwick assuring that he was fit to return to play. But this decision was heavily criticised over concerns of re-injury when other back row combinations could have been chosen instead. It is important to ask, what message does the decision to start Curry send to fans, particularly younger players? 

Unlike the elites, amateur players are advised to sit out from competition for a minimum of 21 days after concussion diagnosis

UK government research suggests that to prevent injured players in grassroot sports risking their health by returning to play prematurely it is vital for a player’s close network of teammates and family members to be aware of the dangers of concussion and to encourage and support them to seek treatment.

Unlike the elites, amateur players are advised to sit out from competition for a minimum of 21 days after concussion diagnosis. This came from UK-wide concussion guidance for grassroot sports introduced by the government in 2023. But with no official protocol for return to play after concussion in amateur rugby and limited access to health professionals compared to their elite idols, concussion awareness must continue to improve to protect these players. 

Whether Curry’s quick return to the game was too soon or not, this decision has continued the conversation of rugby’s concussion problem. Recent advancements in rugby law to protect elite players show rugby’s commitment to improve welfare for players. But more research into the impact and prevention of concussion is necessary to protect players of all levels. The effectiveness of the current concussion laws will be continuously assessed in future years and improvement of player welfare should continue to evolve. In the meantime, its vital for the English team to prioritise protecting their players health and set an example for amateur rugby players across the country.

Image: University of the Fraser Valley via Flickr