To tame a tiger
By G.K. Teh
Speaking out against radical Islam and other evils is highly laudable, but are we doing it with the right intentions?
On the morning of January 7, militant Islamists opened fire on the Parisian headquarters of the satirical journal Charlie Hebdo. At least five cartoonists and several members of staff were murdered in an alleged attempt to seek revenge for the newspaper’s outspoken satire and criticism of Islam.
Understandably, we see very little point in negotiating with these madmen and their company (I refer to recent attacks in Dijon and Nantes wherein vehicles were rammed into crowds on busy streets in the name of defending the honour of Islam). It is as if the Islamists actively ignore the logic that using violence to combat ‘Islamophobia’ only serves to invite further criticism.
Criticize we shall. The right to criticize is one of the free world’s most powerful tools. Making compromises on our right to criticism would equal negating the achievements of every struggle for liberty from the 1649 execution of King Charles to present day attempts to topple North Korea’s Kim dynasty.
The trend towards self-censorship – as evidenced in the decision made by most American news sources to pixelate all illustrations and text – comes as unfortunate encouragement for the Islamists. Our hesitance to exercise our right to criticize; to highlight fallacies with deviant Islamism – implies our subservience to one of the most potent threats to society in the 21st century.
We need criticism if we want change to happen. Improvement and revolution is only possible through the mindset that no one is above wrongdoing. We cannot put our power to free speech up for bargaining in addressing the issue of radical Islamist ideology.
No negotiating with lunacy. But are we administering criticism as efficiently as is possible? Virtually all extremist religious associations rely on propaganda. Islamic extremism is no exception. The common terrorist has been brainwashed by ISIS-sanctioned hadiths (doctrines) to perceive the West as a nest of infidels bent on obliterating all which Islam represents. We do battle with enemies poisoned with fear and paranoia.
In case it is not obvious, let me iterate: fighting poison with poison does not work. We can’t cure paranoia by unleashing paranoia fodder with abandon. Illustrations of an ISIS militant beheading the Prophet Muhammad (October 2014), of an Orthodox Jew pushing a man in Islamic garb (September 2012) and of a naked woman with a burqa flowing from her rear (October 2010) serves not so much in promulgating fair criticism of radical Islam, but more in confirming the accusations of the West purported in the hadiths. This gives the radicals the perfect excuse to execute violence against our society.
We must reevaluate our ways in criticizing radical Islam. We must distinguish between ‘questioning’ and ‘mockery’. This distinction begins with the intent in criticism. Those who question seek to discuss ideology and highlight its fallacies. This has been a common scholarly practice amongst Islamic scholars since the 9th century.
In contrast, those who mock seek to incite emotional response – laughter from the mockers, and explosive fury from the mocked. It is this latter reaction that has (and will) bring formidable consequences. There is no question to whether we are entitled to the right to criticize, but does the same hold true for mockery? For the sake of lives, the pragmatist in me thinks not.
Most of us would not tame a wild tiger by walking into its den coated in steak juices, so why do so many of us throw this logic out of the window when it comes to Islam and satire?
Photograph from Wikipedia Commons, US Department of Agriculture.

