To sue or not to sue, that is Liz Truss’ question
By Jussi-Peter Hill
On the 9th January, Prime Minister Keir Starmer received an official “cease and desist” letter from former Conservative Prime Minister Liz Truss, for what she believes are his repeated “false and defamatory” claims that she “crashed the economy” while in office. But does the threat carry any weight, or is it merely symbolic political posturing for the media from Ms Truss?
Ms Truss has consistently denied Starmer’s claims against her, instead blaming policies at the Bank of England. As the crash mostly concerned government bonds (and thus pensions and mortgages), with no fall in GDP or rise in unemployment, Ms Truss has even claimed that the economic shock following her ‘mini-Budget’ cannot be considered a crash in the first place.
This defence of her economic policy comes under serious strain however when we view the realities of the repercussions that followed the mini-Budget. There was a rapid backtracking of some of her key policies, like removing the top rate of income tax which would have resulted in a large tax cut for some of the wealthiest earners. Soon Truss had replaced her own chancellor KwasHoi Kwarteng, who had helped mastermind the mini-Budget with her. Indeed, less than five weeks after the mini-Budget’s announcement, Truss herself had resigned, leaving her Britain’s shortest-serving prime minister. It seems highly doubtful any of these dramatic political disruptions would have occurred if a backlash had not developed in the immediate wake of Miss Truss’ policies.
It is understandable, however, why the former Prime Minister may feel compelled to defend her actions in the mini-Budget from political attack. In the cease-and-desist letter, she lays out her belief that Mr Starmer’s accusations of her crashing the economy contributed to her defeat in the 2024 general election. Ms Truss lost the Southwest Norfolk constituency in a shocking victory for Labour, as the seat had previously been considered safe for the Conservatives. The former Prime Minister at least partly blames what she sees as reputational harm incurred from Mr Starmer’s accusations for this.
The Labour government, for its part, has made clear it feels little pressure to change its language regarding Ms Truss or the mini-Budget
However, it seems highly unlikely that this cease-and-desist letter represents much in the way of a genuine legal threat to Sir Kier Starmer and the Labour government. As Brett Wilson LLP laid out in a blog post the day after Ms Truss sent her letter, there is no explicit threat of legal action in her words, and she would need to send a ‘letter of claim’ to initiate libel action. This would support the idea that Miss Truss’ letter to the PM is more of a defiant political gesture, one that lacks much substance in ways of legal threat.
Brett Wilson also notes previous court rulings have allowed wider freedom of expression during election campaigns, including a case involving Ms Truss’ predecessor as PM, Boris Johnson, again making success a more unlikely outcome for Ms Truss.
The Labour government, for its part, has made clear it feels little pressure to change its language regarding Ms Truss or the mini-Budget. The spokesman for the Prime Minister instead suggested Ms Truss send similar letters to ‘millions of people’ who Labour claims suffered because of her mini-Budget.
Clearly, then, the letter from Ms Truss does not constitute a serious legal threat to the Prime Minister, and it is certainly not being taken as one by his party. Given the reasons laid out in the article, if Ms Truss were to try and take Sir Kier Starmer to court for his comments, her chance of victory seems remote, with the court ruling likely leading only to more political humiliation. Instead, it may represent an attempt to defend or even begin restoring her political legacy and regain Ms Truss a foothold in the national conversation once again.
Image Credit: Simon Dawson / No10 Downing Street

