Tim Hunt deserved to be sacked
“Let me tell you about my trouble with girls. Three things happen when they are in the lab: you fall in love with them, they fall in love with you, and when you criticise them they cry.”
Those were the now infamous comments made by Sir Tim Hunt last month, winner of the Nobel Prize, at, shockingly, a conference about women in science.
Since then, Sir Hunt has resigned from his honorary post at UCL. He did not face much resistance from the university, which was keen to distance itself from the sexist remarks: “Our ambition is to create a working environment in which women feel supported and valued at work”, said Professor Michael Arthur, President of UCL.
However, recently there has been a backlash. Twenty honorary fellows wrote to The Times to express disapproval of UCL’s treatment of Hunt, and Jonathan Dimbleby went as far as to resign from his UCL post in protest. Supporters of Hunt say that he followed his remarks with heavy praise for women in science, and that the initial comments were lighthearted and said in jest.
The thing is, Hunt’s ‘joke’ wasn’t very funny. The comments were made by someone extremely privileged (Hunt, who is white, male, and upper-middle class) at the expense of an underrepresented group in science (women).
“It was an unbelievably stupid thing to say”, Hunt’s wife Mary Collins said. Indeed, people say stupid things. Nonetheless, this is no excuse. According to WISE, the campaign to encourage more women in science, technology and engineering, only 13% of workers in these sectors are women.
When comments like Hunt’s are seen as acceptable because it was merely ‘silly’ or ‘jokey’, we undermine the real struggle women face in achieving success in science. EU research found that in science and engineering, women make up 35% of PhD graduates, 32% of entry level jobs, 23% of middle ranking jobs, and only 11% of professors. There is clearly something fishy going on: whether it’s the implicit biases of male interviewers, girls being socially conditioned to be less assertive and more self-deprecating from a young age, or negative attitudes to maternity leave making it hard for women to progress in their careers when they return to work, comments such as Hunt’s add to the hostile culture surrounding women in science.
The feminist furore that has led to Hunt’s stepping down has been criticised as ‘disproportionate’. But the statistics which show that a young boy is more than five times as likely to have a job in science than his female counterpart means that a furore is exactly what is needed. Society needs to demonstrate that it is standing up for these girls, and encouraging them against the current odds.
Of course these are structural problems, and it’s unfortunate that Hunt has had to take a hit for society’s faults. But if Hunt had made similar comments about people of colour, or LGBTQ people, then, quite rightly, we would not be defending him. We need to start taking the rights of women just as seriously, and condemn those who add to a culture of hostility.
It’s regrettable that one Nobel prize winner has had to resign. But it’s even more regrettable that many potential Nobel prize winners are deterred from science by comments like Hunt’s.
Photograph: Paloma Baytelman

