Tiffany McDaniel: feminist agency in small-town America
By Hannah Crockett
Tiffany McDaniel’s Betty (2020) is a harrowing yet humanising depiction of womanhood in rural Ohio during the 1960s, winding through the multi-generational landscape of pain, violence, and trauma, against the backdrop of Appalachian hills. Betty Carpenter, as a young girl of mixed indigenous and white heritage, finds herself branching between clashing matriarchal systems of her Cherokee culture, and the harshly contrasting patriarchal society outside of her home. Storytelling evolves into the vessel through which Betty maintains connection to her culture, her ancestors, and her father, who is her only family member who shares her Cherokee appearance.
“A girl comes of age against the knife. She must learn to bear its blade. To be cut. To bleed. To scar over and still somehow, be beautiful and with good enough knees to take the sponge to the kitchen floor every Saturday.”
Raw and unyielding, McDaniel’s juxtaposition of the brutality of the human experience against the harsh, yet beautiful natural world, explores how pain is not defined to human experience, but part of the wider cycle of life. The earth endures and regenerates, as do women navigating their pain, emerging stronger, yet forever marked by their experiences. McDaniel uses this discourse to depict the symbioses between pain, womanhood and nature.
This duality of nature, with its ability to nurture and destroy, mimics Cherokee ideation of women – where pain, power, autonomy, and beauty intersect
With the fertile yet scarred lands, the sharp edges of wilderness, and the relentless weather describing the falling rain as if punishing the earth with its heavy hands, the natural world is depicted as a brutal storyteller. The trees are not static – they whisper. Rivers don’t flow – they hold secrets, stories, and pain. This duality of nature, with its ability to nurture and destroy, mimics Cherokee ideation of women – where pain, power, autonomy, and beauty intersect. McDaniel unites and embodies womanhood and the natural world, suggesting pain as the embodying concept. Thus, McDaniel uses Cherokee matriarchal folklore to contrast the patriarchal world that Betty navigates.
“To the Cherokee, the earth had a gender. The mother. The she”
Pain is depicted as a fundamental force of survival, and as a catalyst for violent transformation for both McDaniel’s characters and the landscape that surrounds them, challenging our conceptions of pain, suggesting that it transcends human feeling, yet simultaneously humanising women and their bodies.
Ripping the two apart, McDaniel distinguishes pain and violence, whilst refusing to romanticise either. Pain as renewal, violence as destruction – McDaniel paints how diminishing women’s voices enables violence to transform into the greater evil that is generational trauma. Inherited pain is deeply woven in Betty, an example being her 9th birthday, to which her mother told her the story of cruelties she suffered at the hands of her own father at the same age. We see how women bear the brunt of generational trauma, as they inherit it and are begged to hold onto it for as long as they can. Yet, storytelling becomes the vessel for confronting and breaking this cycle, as seen by the knowledge gained by her mother’s story, Betty is later able to recognise violence within her own household and is able to confront it. This intergenerational cycle of pain shows how trauma isn’t individual, it is inherited and shared, with each generation carrying the weight of the previous generation’s experiences, and shows how giving these generational traumas a voice via storytelling, confronts them, empowers women to navigate their pain.
Pain as renewal, violence as destruction – McDaniel paints how diminishing women’s voices enables violence to transform into the greater evil that is generational trauma
Tangled in the undergrowth of matriarchy, trauma, and survival, Betty and her father use storytelling to navigate the varying violence they both suffer. Her father’s storytelling, rooted in Cherokee folklore and motifs of gardening and the natural world, transforms trauma into something they can shape rather than be shaped by, and yields a framework for rejecting the rigid gender norms that surround them both. Betty’s father strays from westernised gender norms and notions of masculinity through visceral storytelling and compassion as he raises his children, thus providing an interesting cultural framework for understanding gender politics.
Tiffany McDaniel’s ‘Betty’ is a visceral exploration of how pain, violence, and generational trauma are intricately knotted and reminiscent of the natural world, presenting pain as a fundamental aspect of identity and autonomy, enabling women to confront and reclaim their experiences, thus, breaking cycles of inherited pain. McDaniel advocates for re-examining our perceptions of pain and womanhood, where embracing our stories fosters healing across generations, while calling out the silencing and marginalisation of women, their bodies, and their voices, especially within the intersections of race, class, and gender. Betty embodies the struggle for bodily autonomy and voice, yet is a vivid example of feminist agency, resisting the forces that attempt to diminish her. McDaniels calls for you to be the same as Betty.
Image credit: Tiffany McDaniel

