This is not a review: The Bald Prima Donna

by Ben Weaver-Hincks

In the almost puritan sparseness of the St. John’s College chapel, sit a bourgeois English couple and a human clock. Durham theatre can throw up these uncomfortably bizarre moments; fortunately, A Tree in a Teacup’s production of Ionesco’s ‘The Bald Prima Donna’ did so entirely intentionally.

The plot – if one can call it that – is simple: one couple visits another for dinner, with interruptions from a maid and a fire chief. However, interspersed with nonsense stories, sustained silences, non sequiturs and a door-bell that rings apparently of its own accord, the play becomes a classic piece of absurdist theatre – Lewis Carroll for grownups. Matt Robinson’s direction plays off these aspects, achieving a nuanced tone and rarely missing a trick.

Far from being purely comic, nonsense conceals a deeply disturbing set of truths in the play, and this production succeeded in conveying the dark notes amongst the absurd. As Mrs Smith, Rebecca Wallbank was exceptional. She delivered comic lines in a way that told of the futility of communication, so that she seemed at the same time both possessed and clear-headed – think Katharine Hepburn in ‘The Lion in Winter’. Lyle Bushe as her husband was equally enigmatic in his delivery. Whilst he sometimes tried to articulate the humour in lines that spoke for themselves, he nonetheless managed to maintain control over an extraordinary range of volume and tone, and injected energy into the play whenever this faltered.

As the Martins, William Hockedy and Connie Byrne-Shore delivered somewhat more muted performances, which nonetheless provided a refreshing counterpoint to the frenzied intensity of their hosts. Byrne-Shore’s completely deadpan tone was spot-on, and though her apparent boredom initially jarred with the energy of the first scene, the rhythm that she maintained ensured that it met its mark. Hockedy was fantastically creepy, only occasionally slipping into cliché, and delivering a lively comic performance when this was required of him, including a particularly brave act of biblio-mastication.

Each actor perhaps took a moment to win over the audience – with the possible exception of Carys Harper, whose charismatic, if somewhat caricatured, turn as the maid set its pace from the offset. Henry Yorke, as the fire chief, opted for a comic awkwardness that proved hugely popular with the audience, and brought unlikely empathy to a challenging role. Finally, the decision to use the dinner-jacketed Will Tyson to serve as the clock was unusual, but not out of keeping with the script’s playfulness. It created some slightly uncomfortable comedy, however, most notably when he was very nearly maimed by a flying book.

Overall, the cast forms a strong ensemble, whilst retaining the sense of desperate isolation necessary to the play’s success. However, Ionesco’s work demands an unusual form of reflectiveness of its actors. To have any greater significance than pure nonsense, characters need to seem at least somewhat aware of their absurdity and futility; and yet, apply too much meta-theatrical self-consciousness, and such meaning collapses. There were times when the actors slipped from the tight-rope in this regard, either becoming overly aware of the audience, or not seeming to find the ridiculous in their own words. By and large, however, they pulled it off. And, despite attempts to break down the fourth wall, the play asked mercifully little of its audience. Though the drama threatened at times to spill out into the pews, it was for the most part kept on stage, bringing the script to the fore.

I left, still clutching my ticket, which I now realised had the words ‘This is not a ticket’ printed on it, and passed the cast, who were applauding the audience. Perhaps there had been moments when this production had played upon absurdity gratuitously, over-doing the comic aspects of the script; but despite this, it never lost its sinister undertones. To see such a performance on any Durham stage would have been a pleasure; to see it in a little-used venue, performed by several unfamiliar faces was wonderfully revitalizing. Even Ionesco’s bleak portrayal of the human condition was not enough to take away from my newly-restored faith in the potential of student theatre.