‘This is life or death’: does Britain’s policy match its climate change rhetoric?

By Alex Curtis

Boris Johnson’s warning that the international community needs to do more, on the second day of COP26, is part of wider British rhetoric surrounding the climate. The threat of anthropogenic climate change is one that is often difficult to comprehend and induces all sorts of cognitive obstacles, including the complexity of the evidence supporting the impact of climate change.

However, the past year has seen a marked shift in British policy towards the environment. This is epitomised by the Government stating that “tackling climate change and biodiversity loss” is its “number one international priority”. Hence, the recent publication of Britain’s integrated review and COP26 in Glasgow are the perfect litmus tests for the importance of the environment to Britain’s strategic agenda.

Before analysing British efforts in climate leadership, we must unpack the vocabulary that surrounds it. Namely, anthropogenic climate change. The concept of the Anthropocene was introduced by Paul Crutzen to capture the shift in relationship between humans and the environment. He argued that the Anthropocene originated during the Industrial Revolution as humanity’s use of fossil fuels rapidly expanded. This, therefore, marked a new geological epoch where the human imprint on the global environment grew to rival some of the great forces of nature. 

The past year has seen a marked shift in British policy towards the environment

A consequence of this new geological era has been human-induced shifts in our climate, potentially leading to melting arctic ice releasing ancient viruses and microbes, and wildfires becoming twice as destructive as they are today.

Significantly, the danger of climate change is no longer just environmental. For every half-degree of warming, it is predicted that society will see a 10-20% rise in the likelihood of armed conflict. Resource-based conflict could also increase as food security is put under pressure from temperature rises. Thus, anthropogenic climate change could increase the frequency of conflict, alter its nature and inflict lasting economic damage. With such a complex and potentially high-level threat from anthropogenic climate change, does Britain’s response adequately match the threat landscape?

Notably, in March 2021 the Government published the integrated review, highlighting climate change as the number one priority for Britain. This marks a distinct shift in Government messaging and places climate action firmly on the legislative agenda. The £1 billion commitment to carbon capture technology is an important step in ensuring that climate governance is not just tokenistic emission reduction policies.

However, the integrated review does have gaps in its strategic approach to climate change. For example, it does not consider the role of solar geoengineering and other such emerging technologies. Fundamentally, the integrated review still lacks the holistic approach to climate change, continuing to frame it as a strategic afterthought to other security concerns. 

The Ministry of Defence (MoD) Climate Change and Sustainability Strategic Approach provides a much more comprehensive plan for the UK to mitigate against climate change. This is done through setting measurable objectives and emphasising the role of British leadership in achieving global carbon neutrality. Future climate policy documents should follow this framework when assessing the geopolitical impact of climate change.

British strategic interests are coalescing around climate change

That said, despite the limitations of the Integrated Review, its value lies not simply in its analysis, but in how it shapes national and international policy discourse surrounding climate change. The Integrated Review is part of the wider policy landscape which is elevating the importance of anthropogenic climate change in British foreign policy. Britain’s presidency of COP through the coming year is a critical juncture in British climate policy. This is the perfect opportunity for Britain to show bold leadership and prove that their commitment to tackling climate change is more than rhetoric.

In terms of the COP26 negotiations, these are often secretive and the full influence of British presidency is not yet clear. However, ‘behind the scenes’ analysis of the Paris Agreement demonstrated that French leadership was essential to the passage of the agreement.

Moreover, given that the US and China have already agreed to work together to deliver the 1.5C temperature goal set at Paris and COP26 discussions mentioned consigning coal to history, despite this later being watered down, it is reasonable to suggest that British leadership will be of equal, if not greater importance. If this remains the case, Britain will leave the COP presidency with an enhanced international standing.

In short, British strategic interests are coalescing around climate change. The Integrated Review, MoD strategic approach, and the presidency of COP26 are all significant steps in the right direction. However, COP26 and future policy reviews must approach climate change holistically to ensure that it does not become a peripheral issue to wider security challenges. If this is achieved Britain will have helped to shape an effective national and international response to the threat of anthropogenic climate change.

Alex Curtis is a Policy Fellow of The Pinsker Centre, a campus-based think tank which facilitates discussion on global affairs and free speech. The views in this article are the author’s own.

Image: UK Prime Minister’s Office via Wikimedia Commons

Support Palatinate