The world on edge: economic and security impacts of a second Trump administration

By Sam Barrington

With the race for the White House concluded, the certainty of a second Donald Trump administration carries implications that stretch far beyond US borders. The former president’s protectionist rhetoric, set against a backdrop of heightened geopolitical tensions, signals a potential shift in global trade policies and could impact international alliances and the rules-based order that has shaped global diplomacy.

This approach contrasts with traditional models of multilateral cooperation and mutual benefit in international trade. Analysts are now exploring the possible implications of a more politically and economically isolated America. Let us dive into the legacy of the 45th President, the campaign promises and the perspective of nervous onlookers. Analysing these potential changes offers valuable insight into how the 47th President might reshape not only US foreign policy but also the dynamics of international cooperation and stability.

During a discussion at the Economic Club of Chicago a few weeks ago with Bloomberg News Editor-in-Chief John Micklethwait, former President Trump remarked, “The most beautiful word in the dictionary is tariff.” This statement highlights his preference for trade barriers as a means to protect American industries by promoting domestic consumption and encouraging new manufacturing ventures. Mr Trump’s strong emphasis on tariffs reflects a broader economic strategy aimed at fostering American economic interests. 

This is not a new love affair either.

The Trump administration levied tariffs on thousands of products valued, according to The Tax Foundation, at approximately $380 billion in 2018 and 2019. He seems poised to reignite his campaign against what he perceives as unfair practices, doubling down on the notion that America’s economic strength hinges on aggressive tariff policies. Quantifying such policies is a difficult art but economists are generally working under the assumption of a 20% tariff on all imported goods, rising to 60% for Chinese imports. It is important to note however that in Mr Trump’s vision, there’s no upper limit to policies aimed at retaliating against unfair trade partners and restoring America’s industrial might.

The potential consequences of widespread protectionist policies are significant

While harsh tariff policies may aim to protect domestic industry, their ripple effect may disrupt global economic stability and growth. History tells us that as nations are swift to defend their own economic interests, retaliatory measures are to be expected. While most people recall the Cold War for its tense ideological standoff, mired in nuclear threats and regional proxy wars, a notable example of economic retaliation is the Chicken War. In this instance, President Lyndon B. Johnson responded to tariffs placed by France and West Germany on importing US Chicken with a 25% tax of his own. Although the economic implications of poultry trade may seem minor, the potential consequences of widespread protectionist policies are significant. This sentiment was echoed by the Chinese embassy in Washington, DC following the 2018 tariffs, which stated, “as the Chinese saying goes, it is only polite to reciprocate.”

To mitigate the risk of tariffs, firms look to diversify their supply sources, introducing new trade uncertainties. A more complex supply chain can lead to a more expensive supply chain. Ensuring compliance with international regulations and coordinating supply through newfound channels points to delay, disruption and higher operational costs. Complexity, and the associated difficulties in prediction, may also lead to market volatility, damaging the ability of firms to develop long-term investment strategies and plan for growth. The effects of a potential protectionist escalation are, of course, most profound in China where firms will face increasing pressures from both within and outside its borders.

Donald Trump’s tariffs could disrupt the path of disinflation, leading to higher interest rates and reducing economic momentum

US restrictions, combined with potential coordinated efforts from the EU and other US allies, aiming to curb risks to the transatlantic partnership, as shall be discussed, may have wide-reaching effects on the global economy. By nature, economists generally view tariffs as inflationary, as they raise import costs, pressuring central banks to raise interest rates. These higher rates, reducing the propensity to borrow, discourage investment and consumer spending.

CEO of the Institute of International Finance Tim Adams, warned that Donald Trump’s tariffs could disrupt the path of disinflation, leading to higher interest rates and reducing economic momentum. Moreover, recent IMF modelling indicates that escalating tariffs could reduce global output, harming economies through the disruption of supply chains and altering trading flows through more expensive and less efficient routes.

A destabilised transatlantic partnership … contributes not just to slower economic performance but broader security concerns

The ripple effect of harsh tariff policies are likely to be felt most strongly by close trading partners like the EU. The Anti-Coercion Instrument (ACI), entering into force in December 2023, was presented by the European Commission as a means to deter and respond to economic coercion, as outlined in their presentation press release. Developed with former president in mind, the ACI gives the EU scope to impose retaliatory measures deemed to exert excessive economic pressure on the EU. Despite proposed tariffs on politically sensitive US products being reversed by the EU following President Biden’s inauguration, they demonstrate a commitment to vigilant action against any unilateral action from the US.

A destabilised transatlantic partnership, represented by reduced trading volumes, low investor confidence, fractured supply-chains and diminished foreign direct investment, contributes not just to slower economic performance but broader security concerns. Whether the EU and other trading partners respond in tit-for-tat fashion or coordinated negotiation remains unclear, but preparations are likely underway to assess the impact on key industries and to devise strategies to maintain economic stability.

Micklethwait stressed that the repercussions of harsh tariff policy extend beyond purely economic concern and into the realm of security. He argued that the Cold War was in part won through the rallying of allies and isolationist policies risk undermining these alliances, weakening the united front essential for addressing today’s global security challenges. The former president, who has promoted an “America First” approach and expressed skepticism toward globalization, has previously described NATO as “obsolete” and has criticized alliance members for, in his view, relying too heavily on U.S. defence spending.

Mr Trump’s approach to alliances … and trade policies has raised concerns about potential changes in the stability and predictability of the global landscape

According to the Director of Foreign Policy Research at the Brookings Institution, the Trump administration intensified its efforts to persuade South Korea to increase its financial contributions for the support of the 30,000 American troops stationed in the country as of November 2019. In response to this pressure, South Korea consented to a 10% increase in its payments, while former US Defence Secretary Mark Esper emphasized the need for a further “substantial increase” in line with Mr Trump’s objectives. When interviewed by Time Magazine in April this year, Mr Trump indicated that he would resume his first term negotiating stance of holding the threat of withdrawal over Seoul’s head in order to extract higher payments. These developments underscore the complexities of U.S. foreign policy and the potential ramifications for international alliances and security cooperation.

In a world facing increasingly multi-faceted security challenges, from cyber threats to climate change and everything in between, Mr Trump’s approach to alliances, global institutions, and trade policies has raised concerns about potential changes in the stability and predictability of the global landscape, with indications from his current campaign suggesting a more assertive position compared to his previous term heightening concerns about America’s global role. Would this isolationist vision create a global power vacuum, or does it signal the reshaping of the world order, one defined less by collective security and more by transactional power plays? Whether America’s security and influences are strengthened or undermined by this approach remains to be seen, and as the world watches its next move, the question lingers: can a nation truly lead from the sidelines?

Image credit: Official White House Photo by Sheila Craighead via Picryl