The Week Force: Leading by example?

by Jonny Bowers

I was trying to decide what to write about this week when I stumbled across an article on the Guardian online entitled: “It’s time scientists set an example by reducing their carbon footprint”. The article in question was well written, and well worth a read (although the Palatinate editors may not thank me for promoting another newspaper). However, I’m not sure whether I agree with its sentiments, which is not to say that I disagree, I’m simply unsure. Rarely have I read something and been unable to be sure of my own opinion, so this seems to be a rare opportunity to write without being completely biased.

Firstly, you have the argument which the writer presents: scientists, especially those preaching that carbon emissions should be cut, should cut their own emissions first as an example. Instead of flying around the world to their numerous conferences, they should do as much as possible from the comfort of their own desks, e-conferences should become commonplace, scientists should start off the move towards more efficient cars and they should generally act as a community to reduce their emissions. In principle I agree that you should practice what you preach, and not just because the Black Eyed Peas said so. It’s important that the scientists are seen to follow their own advice and everyone is seen to be making an effort to reduce our carbon footprint. I once read an article criticising Al Gore which implied that just because he flew around the country promoting his film “An Inconvenient Truth” it couldn’t possibly have any truth in it. Now there are many inaccuracies and problems with that film, but Gore’s decision to travel around promoting it is not a reason for defaming it! So, it obviously is important for scientists to show that they are making an effort, not just because they have a moral obligation to do so, but because there is a public perception that demands that they do. Unfortunately this is apparently an area where “do as I say, not as I do” will not cut the mustard.

Then there’s the other side of the argument. Nobody looks at an economist who is lecturing on how multinational corporations are ruining our high street diversity and analyses his clothes. Did his underwear come from Topman? The audience is indifferent and he is merely presenting his evidence to them, with a small moral suggestion as to what they should do. So why is climate science such a contentious issue? Is it not the prerogative of any climate scientist to get the message out no matter what the cost? If he wastes a tonne of carbon dioxide flying to Australia to give a speech at a convention, is this not offset by the thousands of tonnes which he could prevent being released? Unfortunately this is a global issue, and as a result scientists do need to have a global presence. It’s not enough just to do good, their moral obligation is to preach to others about the need to live in a more green, sustainable way. In an ideal world, it would be possible to live a perfectly green life and also spread this message, but in the world that we currently inhabit, surely the latter is more important?

It’s something that I’m still not sure about. As a small aside, there’s an equally ruffled reader commenting on said story who goes by the name “JBowers”. I would just like to pop out a disclaimer: it’s not me, and it’ll probably be the last time I read comments on a climate change article, because they just make me angry!

As you may have noticed, there was no show this week, but make sure you tune in to “The Week Force” next Saturday (the 3rd) when we’ll be back on air and raring to spread some more science. There may even be riveting (!) live updates from the IPCC’s Durban conference.