The Week Force: Don’t be good to bad guys, or the babies will come for you!

by Jonny Bowers

It was the title of this article that first thing that attracted me to it. Emblazoned on a website I recently discovered “Babies Embrace Punishment Earlier Than Previously Thought, Study Suggests” blared out and caught my attention. Eager to find out about another glaringly false story about masochistic toddlers “needing a good smack” I read on. To my surprise, it was not condoning corporal punishment in the manner of the Daily Mail, but was actually a story about a recent paper published in a well respected American journal, about how one hundred 8 month old babies reacted to various puppet scenarios being played out before them. It had always been suggested that children of this age universally preferred to see kind acts being carried out, but this study apparently provided oodles of evidence to the contrary.

The study focused around the babies being shown a series of four stories involving puppets. In these settings some puppets would act negatively towards their comrades and some much more positively, setting some of the puppets up as “bad” and some as “good”.  In the later scenes, other puppets would award or steal toys from the original characters. The babies were then prompted to choose their favourite characters out of the new puppets i.e. the ones who awarded or stole the toys. Perhaps unsurprisingly the babies chose those who awarded “good” characters with toys, but also chose those who stole from – or punished – the “bad” characters. Prof. Kiley Hamlin, from the University of California, Berkley, and the lead author of the article was quoted “by eight months, babies have developed nuanced views of reciprocity and can conduct these complex social evaluations much earlier than previously thought,” Or in my simple language, babies have picked up on the idea of punishment, but not only that, if you’re nice to a bad guy, they don’t like you.

Prof Hamlin explained “These findings suggest that, from as early as eight months, we are watching for people who might put us in danger and prefer to see antisocial behaviour regulated”. So it’s an in-built survival tactic. Somewhere along the line we evolved the ability to condone bad things happening to bad people. Hamlin elaborated that we will probably all recognise the good feeling of seeing a bad guy get his comeuppance in a film, or have seen other children at school go and tell teacher about bad behaviour – because they want to see the wrongdoer punished, it also explains why people cheered at public executions.  These instincts are, according to Hamlin, deeply rooted in our nature for interests of self preservation, we couldn’t survive as such sociable creatures if we weren’t infected with the desire for retribution; we would simply be cheated and exploited.

So even babies are programmed to hate someone that commits something that is, in their eyes, wrong, and anyone who associates with that person. According to the psychology professors over the pond this is the most human and normal of reactions. If this is so, why can I not help feeling depressed slightly at this story? In my mind, notwithstanding what someone is perceived to have done, we should reserve judgement on them until we have the full picture. Why did the babies not feel the need to ask if the “bad” characters had reasons for being bad, maybe they didn’t realise that they were behaving negatively to the other puppets. As humans, are we always doomed to leap in this way before we look? Because instantly feeling the need for retributive punishment seems, to me, to be a very inhumane reaction. I almost want to go to a public execution, just to defy myself not to cheer.

Tune into “The Week Force” on Saturdays at 3pm on Purple Radio!