The war between law and the government

By Tom Wilson

We seem to be locked in a deadly battle. Against us are an omnipotent, evil group of judges ruling over Europe in a despotic fashion. These tyrants are oppressing everything that the common Briton holds dear. If they’re not stopped, Britain, as we know it, will be ruined.

This is a view espoused by almost every newspaper over the past few weeks. It was sparked by the ruling given by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) regarding prisoners receiving the vote (incidentally, this is something completely different from the European Union – a basic fact that most of the media fail to grasp). They declared our historic blanket ban incompatible with human rights, and said it was therefore illegal. However, the suggestion that this represents an undemocratic blow to Britain’s sovereignty, that it is a sign of European tyranny eroding the power of British legislators, is not only false, but also completely ridiculous.

I should begin by stating that I support the ban, and have argued as such in a previous edition of Palatinate. However, this does not prevent me from offering three simple facts that highlight the farcical nature of such an image.

Firstly, the ECtHR was created by the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This is an international treaty ratified immediately after the Second World War, a treaty that Britain itself initiated, drafted and signed. For over 60 years we have been a party to the Convention, and over this time, numerous cases have been found against various governments, and numerous more found in favour of these governments. However, the UK has accepted the various rulings because we have voluntarily become a member of the treaty. We can leave at any time. Remaining subject to the treaty is an expression, not erosion, of our sovereignty.

Secondly, the Court is made up of one judge from every member state of the Convention; at this point there are 46. These are appointed by the national Governments. They are not elected, but are chosen by the politicians, the very people who have paradoxically claimed that these judges are not legitimate. The most integral part of any legal system, whether national or international, is judicial independence. If we were to elect our judges, their independence would be compromised. Britain remains a world leader on such matters, and it was after our legal system that the court was modelled. If you have a problem with unelected judges, you have a problem with the most successful, most prestigious, most respected legal system in the world: our own.

Finally, it is also worth noting, without descending into a law essay, that there is a principle adopted by the court known as the “margin of appreciation”. This means that considerable, even excessive, weight is accorded to the opinions of the national governments, such as our own, in cases that come before it. This is done to such an extent that the majority of lawyers lament its existence.

Regardless, this is the clearest sign that the Court is not an autocratic oppressive European executive, but instead an institution secondary to member states. It is an institution created by, respected by and maintained by individual member states. All of whom express their sovereignty, a sovereignty respected by the Court, by remaining a party to the ECHR.

I have given three reasons that you should not believe the storm whipped up by the media. I am patriotic, I would describe myself as conservative and I oppose giving prisoners the vote. However, none of these facts prevent me from being proud of our nation’s membership of a pioneering human rights treaty. The rights guaranteed under it are relatively narrow. We may disagree as to their scope, we may disagree as to their application, however if we are to do so, we should at least understand how they work.

Next time you hear Ken Clarke, David Cameron or The Daily Mail prattle on about how terrible the ECtHR is, remember this: in a second we could withdraw from the treaty. It would be easy, the ramifications may be wide, but we could do so nevertheless. Yet, what most informed politicians, and all lawyers, understand, is that this treaty is a good thing. It is what has given us equal rights for homosexuals and transsexuals, it is what has guaranteed free speech and eradicated much of the arbitrariness that used to plague our government. The ECtHR is not an excessively liberal bunch of Europeans who are thrilled at the thought of bashing Britain. That is simply a portrayal that sells newspapers and wins votes. If you want to believe such an image, you are free to do so, but only because of your right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the ECHR, a right you can enforce in court if it were ever to be removed.