The Vicar of Dibley review: ‘gentle comedy’
By Becky Wilson
As those familiar with the television series know, The Vicar of Dibley is a gentle comedy which follows the struggles of an endlessly enthusiastic female vicar who finds herself working for a village in which nothing ever happens.
Director Steph Horrocks expressed her reluctance to ‘lean too heavily’ upon the universally-adored TV series, but Oook’s production inevitably borrows quite considerably from it. Much of the ensemble characters – most notably the dithering Jim Trott (Ross McCreery) and pedantic Frank Pickle (Freddie Ridell) – could have been poor impersonations, but in general the cast did a fantastic job at bringing out the comedy of their characters and adding distinctive twists of their own. Wilf Wort’s Owen is a particular highlight, his lustful advances on Geraldine delivered to comedic perfection through a contorted face and gruff west-country accent.
Charlotte Thomas was perfectly cast as the Rev. Geraldine. From her first high-heeled strut into the church to her very last scene, she emits a warmth which binds her and all the other characters together. However, what makes her so watchable is not this warmth, but her understated deadpan delivery, and occasional despairing looks at the audience, as if inviting us to sympathise with her increasingly ridiculous predicaments. If anything, Thomas should be more confident in her sarcasm, as this is one of the most engaging, funny aspects of the play.
The development of Alice (Joanna Boyle) and Hugo (Eugene Smith)’s relationship fuels much of the plot, and we follow the deliciously awkward pair from first kiss to wedding. Both do a good job with their characters. Smith is endearing as the bumbling posh Hugo, and bounces off all the other characters well. Boyle embodies Alice’s over-the-top physicality and dazed facial expressions.
It was a wise move to stage this production in a church. Rather than merely using it as a theatre, Horrock and her production team have taken advantage of every feature of the space. The audience, sitting in the pews, becomes a church congregation; the altar is used as Geraldine’s kitchen; and Mrs Cropley (Kitty Briggs) genuinely plays the Bridal Chorus on the organ. In fact, the wedding scene is undoubtedly a highlight of the entire play, complete with teletubbies, a teapot costume and starburst confetti. There is one ingeniously dramatic interruption, which I will not spoil for future audiences, which is handled with perfect comic timing.
The problems with this production lie mostly with pace. Naturally, as a live piece of theatre rather than an edited television show, it is impossible to cut between two scenes, in different locations and with different characters, as quickly as a camera. As a result of this, there is much clumsy rushing on and off of stage, and shuffling between the meeting room and Geraldine’s house. Given that many scenes are extremely brief, the pace is slowed down almost to a halt. This problem could have been surmounted by some shrewd editing of the script, increased music in scene transitions, or perhaps even by using a split stage. Another minor criticism is that it is occasionally difficult to hear the actors speak. The acoustics of the church mean that a few lines, poorly-projected or delivered to the back of the stage, are completely lost to the audience.
Although the majority of jokes go down well, some are particularly laboured, like Mrs Cropley’s terrible cooking and some particularly cheesy puns (see ‘Hamlet’ being misheard as ‘ham omelette’). These do not get a laugh the first time, so when they are returned to they become slightly painful to watch. Nevertheless, this is more a fault of the play itself than Ooook!’s production of it.
This production by no means breaks any boundaries, but with its gentle comedy and light-hearted subject matter, it isn’t trying to. The play itself does not stray very far at all from the television series. But why change something that already works? With strong comedic performances from all the cast, The Vicar of Dibley is undoubtedly a success.
‘The Vicar of Dibley’ will run until Fri 24th June at Elvet Methodist Church. Book your tickets here.
Photograph: Andy Ball
