The UN declaration of human rights (and wrongs?)
By Carolina Hughes
On 10th December 1948, the United Nations (UN) proclaimed the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR). December this year will see the UDHR’s 75th anniversary – but it may not be a time to celebrate. The UDHR faced criticisms at its inception regarding the validity of its universalist application, and there are arguments that suggest this is perhaps still prevalent today.
The UN modelled the UDHR predominantly in response to the human rights travesties that occurred in the World Wars. It aimed to make human rights applicable in all areas of life, rather than just political protections, to emphasise its truly universal application.
Its continued relevance today indicates that the drafting committee thoroughly deliberated and cautiously authored UDHR articles; however, the Declaration was not met without resistance in 1948. During the drafting, only 58 Member States were involved, and only 8 individuals formed the committee responsible – many Asian and African states were under colonial rule or had not yet come into existence.
Evidently, the UDHR’s claimed ‘universalism’ was curated by the western world’s colonisers. However, the academic Klug argues that this was balanced by the UDHR’s stated purpose in combatting colonial slavery, genocide, racism, and sexism.
December this year will see the UDHR’s 75th anniversary – but it may not be a time to celebrate
Yet as we draw away from the post-war context in 1948 and consider the 191 Member States party to the UN today, it should be questioned whether universalism is an accurate description of the Declaration in 2023.
Arguably, the biggest challenge to this is the growing recognition of intersectionality; the increased globalism of cultures, religions, and languages, and the overlap of these identifiers with race, ethnicity, and gender identity means that ‘universalism’ is in danger of aligning more closely with ‘generalisation’. This is most notable under the controversial Article 16 which protects “Men and women[‘s]… right to marry”.
When considering gender specifically, the UDHR was initially praised for adopting unisex language; yet references to heterosexual marriage and “himself and his family” reiterates that there is a heteronormative universalism within the articles that continues in 2023.
Universalism in the Declaration has meant that there is both “overly universalistic… language” as well as it being “not universal enough” in its applicability. However, in both 1948 and 2023, universalism is perhaps the most appropriate and accurate answer to human rights issues available on a global scale.
Though the UDHR does not legally bind any signing state, it has been internationally respected as having such effect. It has been responsible for inspiring further international and domestic legislation and its continued popularity reaffirms its ability to effectively protect human rights. Though it may not be applicable in every instance, it is evident that the UDHR has merit, as supported by reaching its 75th anniversary.
In both 1948 and 2023, universalism is perhaps the most appropriate and accurate answer to human rights issues available on a global scale
The UDHR had a central aim in the protection of individuals against the cruelties of World War. This setting has since dissolved into a far vaster pool of global concerns and though the 1948 articles are not perfect, they still provide an effective basis upon which more specialised legislation and protection can be formed by governments, institutions, and organisations going forward.
Image: Henry Mühlpfordt via Wikimedia Commons

