The Turkish election: how ostracisation pushes European Turks into the arms of Erdoğan
By Matthew Kavanagh
In late May, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan won a narrow victory over presidential and political rival Kemal Kiliçdaroğlu. This was Erdoğan’s biggest challenge to his 20 year rule over the country. Forced to a second round vote, Erdoğan narrowly clinched victory with 52% of the electorate, a difference of approximately 2.1 million votes between the pair. With margins as small as this, a new important voter block has emerged in Turkey in recent years: overseas voters.
In Europe, in particular, where the majority of the Turkish diaspora resides, there are 3.4 million eligible registered voters. Recognising the importance of this, both campaigns sent representatives to European countries with large Turkish populations. Germany, which has the largest Turkish population in Europe, has become a crucial battleground.
Germany, which has the largest Turkish population in Europe, has become a crucial battleground
In 2023, 1.5 million out of 1.7 million Turks overseas who voted came from Germany. Turks living in Europe overwhelming support Erdoğan, with 59% backing him for the presidency but in Germany the figure is even higher at 67%. Many are puzzled as to why Turks, who live in socially liberal democracies, such as Germany, could back Erdoğan’s conservative agenda. The answer lies in Europe’s migratory history and European Turks’ relationship with their identity.
The reason why Germany has such a large Turkish population dates back to the 1960s. During the post war economic boom Germany did not have enough workers to sustain economic growth projections. In response to this the German government came up with a Guest-Worker visa scheme to attract cheap-labour from south-east Europe and north Africa. The largest group that arrived was Turks from the Central Anatolia region, since it was relatively poorer than other parts of Turkey. The Central Anatolia region is rural and very conservative.
Erdoğan appeals to conservative Anatolian voters through his strongman image and political policies. He is a strong advocate of anti-secularism, he supports strong traditional family values and wants to increase Turkey’s influence on the global stage. Ever since overseas voting was allowed in 2014 he has continued to garner large support in Germany. In the constitutional referendum in 2017 to change Turkey’s parliamentary system to a presidential one he was backed by 63% of German Turks and in 2018 in the previous general election he received 64% of the vote from German Turks.
The Central Anatolian Turks who arrived 60 years ago have made lives for themselves in Germany far away from Turkish politics
However, the Central Anatolian Turks who arrived 60 years ago have made lives for themselves in Germany far away from Turkish politics. It might be expected that these Turks and their children would have felt less affinity to the Turkish state and conservative values. This conservatism has been reinforced by the isolation many German Turks feel from the German state and wider society. The German government expected the Turkish workers to stay temporarily, so little effort was made to teach them German or integrate them into German society and many Turks were treated as outsiders by politicians and the local community. However, many Turks did stay and opted to bring their families along with them.
German citizenship law further complicated these Turks’ sense of belonging to the country. Until 2000, German law didn’t allow for birth right citizenship – meaning that many second or third generation Turks couldn’t become German citizens even though they had lived in the country their entire life. Even when this law was reformed in 2000, ethnic Turks born in Germany could only get citizenship through naturalisation if one parent had lived in Germany for 8 years.
However, the law continued to make it very difficult for Turks to retain dual Turkish citizenship. Germany’s federal structure also meant some states were more reticent in granting naturalisation than others, so the reforms didn’t have the desired effect. This resulted in Turkish naturalisation peaking at 100,000 in 1999 and falling to 16,290 in 2016. In 2016, of the 3 million Turks living in Germany only 246,000 held German citizenship.
Erdoğan has seized upon this lack of German identity and provides a sense of belonging where the German state has failed
As a result of this tumultuous relationship with identity, Turks in Germany maintain a strong connection to their cultural roots. In a survey in 2020 carried out by the Centre for American Progress, 77% of German Turks said they were ‘Turkish first’ and 59.2% said they would feel better living in Turkey. Erdoğan has seized upon this lack of German identity and provides a sense of belonging where the German state has failed. In a speech in Cologne in 2011, he described German Turks as being part of ‘Our great Turkey’ and has attempted to portray himself as defender of the diaspora by saying the purpose of his visit was to ‘enquire about your welfare’.
Erdoğan has always fiercely supported the rights of Turkish descendants throughout Europe. In 2017 he criticised what he referred to “vulgarism, antagonism, and injustice” shown towards Turks, in response to the European Court of Justice making a ruling allowing employers to ban headscarves in the workplace. Erdoğan has taken advantage of the weak integration policy of the guest worker programme. In Austria – which also had a guest worker programme and strict naturalisation laws like Germany – 74% of Turks voted for Erdoğan, whilst in a country like the UK where the guest worker programme never existed and where Turkish immigrants arrived later, 80% of Turks supported Kiliçdaroğlu.
For now, Erdoğan enjoys the support of the European diaspora but only time will tell how much this group will continue to back him. A particularly key issue is how he approaches the rebuilding process after the earthquake which greatly affected the Anatolia region as well as the countries’ economic performance which affects their relatives in Turkey. That being said, the underlying factor is that as long as the Turks continue to feel ostracised from European society, they will be pushed into the waiting arms of Erdoğan.
Image credit: Mstyslav Chernov via Wikimedia Commons
