The troubling ‘romance’ of Fifty Shades of Grey
By Charlotte Cooper

Putting Fifty Shades of Grey onscreen was always going to be tricky. Originally published on a fan fiction site, it was never meant for a mainstream audiences and was sold as a trashy, erotic story, aware of its own ridiculousness. The material is not greatly improved onscreen – the script is painful, the acting wooden and the filmmakers do not seem to understand the ridiculousness of the material they are dealing with. But by backing away from presenting this material as comical, the film has created a troubling moral ground, through romanticising sexual violence and abusive relationships.
The film has been heavily promoted as a serious romance. Numerous posters, interviews and articles have been seen throughout the media over the past few months, as the popularity of the book has ended up verging on the same scale as young adult franchises such as The Hunger Games. In order to sell the film to mainstream audiences, the filmmakers have made the decision to remove the focus from sex and glossed over the book’s trashiness by focusing on the romantic relationship between Ana and Christian. Watching interviews with the film’s leads, Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson, they sell the story as a ‘romance’, describing it to hold a ‘fairy-tale’ element, whilst the promotional features and trailers all contain romantic scenes such of Ana and Christian dancing, dining and whirling around in a helicopter. It was even released on Valentines weekend.
Yet the issue with selling the film as a romance is that it isn’t romantic. The relationship between Ana and Christian is manipulative, cruel and far more disturbing than any of the BDSM scenes. Christian Grey is arguably one of the most disturbing romantic characters ever created. He is a power-hungry, psychologically troubled, self-confessed control freak, yet in Ana’s eyes he still remains incredibly desirable. In order for the audience to understand Ana’s character in the film, the filmmakers gave attempted to depict Christian’s controlling treatment of her in an attractive manner, romanticising it on the screen. Christian controls every aspect of Ana’s life – what she eats, what she wears, when she can go and visit her family. Yet somehow he is so desirable that Ana struggles to bring herself to leave him. She is essentially stuck in an emotionally abusive relationship yet this relationship is still depicted to be desirable and romantic. Although there is a suggestion of female empowerment at the end of the film, when after Ana has let Christian beat her she decides to leave him, there is still a sense of longing depicted as she leaves the room. Despite the fact he has physically abused her, he is still supposed to remain desirable, to both Ana and the audience.
Whilst I appreciate that the relationship between Christian and Ana is simply an attempt to adapt the relationship depicted in the book, creating a mainstream blockbuster from this material normalises their psychologically abusive relationship and romanticises the domestically violent Christian Grey. He is presented as a romantic character throughout the film, and because of his romantic status his psychotic, violent behaviour is rarely subjected to any criticism.
Essentially, the film has found itself on a dangerous middle ground. It is not camp enough to gain a few laughs, nor critical enough of the danger of sexual obsession. Instead it chooses to sell domestic abuse as romance, promoting a social acceptance of sexual violence and rape culture in our society. No matter how much money this film makes, I’m not sure it will justify the rocky moral ground it finds itself on.
