The Tate viewing platform: is visual intrusion a nuisance?
By Helena Dobbs
The Tate viewing platform, which opened in 2016, attracts 50,000 visitors a year as they promise a panoramic view of London’s sweeping skyline, including St Pauls Cathedral, the Thames River, the Shard and… an exclusive look into the interiors of the luxury flats standing 34 metres away.
On 1st February 2023, the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the residents of Neo Bankside, a block of luxury flats lining the Thames in London, who were fighting for their right to privacy against their neighbours, the Tate Modern.
To close the case which had been running since 2017, Lord Leggatt, a Justice of the Supreme Court, ruled that the residents face an unacceptable level of “constant visual intrusion” preventing the “ordinary use and enjoyment” of their homes. The court charged the Tate Modern under the common law of nuisance, extending it to include onlooking as an invasion of privacy.
The court charged the Tate Modern under the common law of nuisance, extending it to include onlooking as an invasion of privacy
The ruling was unexpected. Since 2019, the residents had failed to win over both the High Court and the Court of Appeal who said that visual intrusion should never be considered a nuisance. This explains why people online are, understandably, disappointed by the decision and concerned by the potential consequences. As someone who had no knowledge of the law of nuisance before researching this case, my initial reaction was that visual intrusion should absolutely be considered a nuisance. We live in an age where everything is becoming increasingly visually documented. Taking photos is easier than ever (as is sharing them on an online platform for everyone to see) and security cameras are increasingly prolific; people fly drones for fun. The residents of Neo Bankside objected to their interiors being photographed constantly and posted on social media. They had become the non-consenting art installation of the most renowned modern art museum in the country.
They had become the non-consenting art installation of the most renowned modern art museum in the country
In exploring further, however, I now understand the intricacies of the ruling and the lines that have been blurred. When we start allowing just looking to be an invasion of privacy, where do we draw the line? Will looking through a window become a crime? Will public buildings overlooking roof decks have to board up their windows? These are extreme examples, but you can see why contractors will now have to think twice before putting viewing platforms on public buildings.
More pressingly, it puts fuel in the already roaring and polarised debate surrounding who has the right to space and privacy in urban environments. When living in a city, privacy is always sacrificed to a certain extent. You are met with people every time you leave your house, your neighbours may keep tabs on your comings and goings, and those who live on the ground floor must get used to living with their curtains permanently closed to avoid nosey passers-by. Perhaps those living on the top floors of luxury flats saw themselves as immune from such invasions until, four years into their residency, a viewing platform opened to allow 50,000 people to see straight into their private quarters every year.
Although the concerns people have are legitimate, I must admit that I sympathise with the residents of Neo Bankside. One defence of the Tate stated that the case was no different from one building overlooking another, an occurrence that is inescapable in a capital city. I find this assertion difficult to accept. In most buildings, the people within them are minding their own business, they are not so interested in looking at the view with binoculars or taking photos to post on social media. Even if they are, there is unlikely to be 500,000 people a year coming to the building for the sole motive of looking out the window at what is happening outside.
At the time of a cost-of-living crisis, the case is certainly jarring. It is disappointing that time and money has been put into making rich people living cushy lives more comfortable, while those living in poverty sacrifice their privacy every day. It is also disappointing because most visitors are there for the art and the beautiful view, and the Tate is now unable to provide an opportunity for people to see the London skyline from a public building.
Although the case is closed, the consequences are yet to be decided upon. I hope that the ruling does not result in a closing of the platform and that an alternate conclusion is reached. Perhaps one side could be blocked off to lose the view of the flats?
Sacrificing the word ‘panoramic’ from the attraction’s tagline seems like a satisfactory compromise that would allow visitors to continue viewing the dome of St Pauls from the unique spot across the river.
Photography: Matthew Warring via Unsplash

