The Sinking Ship of State

By Sophie Koch

Growing up in the Indonesian capital of Jakarta, I was aware of the apprehension that accompanied heavy rain. The yearly onslaught of monsoon season and the flash flooding that invariably follows makes commuting a challenge; many roads fill with muddy water, teeming with discarded plastic bags, styrofoam containers and other debris.

A shared resilience surfaces, as uncomfortable solutions are found amidst the chaos. “Tidak apa-apa” (no problem) I once heard a Jakartan say, before he quickly gauged the depth of the flood waters, rolled up his trousers and waded his way through the city. “Tidak apa-apa” housewives would announce as they collected buckets to bail the flood waters from their homes. Nevertheless, beneath this bravado, worries fester about the years to come. Jakarta is becoming increasingly overwhelmed by flooding, with almost half the city sitting beneath sea level and parts sinking by as much as 25 cm every year. Swampy land, 13 heavily polluted rivers, rising sea levels and the city’s chronic reliance on ground water are to blame.

On the last day of 2019, whilst many of us were celebrating New Year’s Eve, Jakarta experienced the worst flooding it has seen in over a decade; 67 died and 400,000 were forced to abandon their homes – a foreshadowing of the troubled days ahead in the new year.

Nevertheless, beneath this bravado, worries fester about the years to come.

In addition to flooding, it is no secret that Jakarta is plagued by a notorious traffic problem: to live and work in the city, is to accept the constant state of ‘macet’ (gridlock). Roads are choked by excessive motorbike and car usage, exacerbated by the lack of public transport options and decades of poor infrastructure planning. The average one-way commute in the city involves sitting on the back of a motorbike inhaling noxious fumes, or in an air-conditioned vehicle if you’re lucky, for 2 hours. As the writer Seno Gumira Ajidarma once bemoaned, the average Jakartan spends 10 years of their life in traffic. For those who have experienced the city, this won’t sound like much of an exaggeration.

It comes as no surprise that the president of Indonesia, Joko Widodo (affectionally known as Jokowi), wants a fresh start: a new government capital on flood proof terrain, which he hopes will help spread Jakarta’s population and so ease its “heavy burdens”. His location of choice? East Kalimantan, on the Jungle island of Borneo – 870 miles away from the current capital. After months of deliberation, this location was chosen for its proximity to growing urban areas, its centralised position in Indonesia and for being an area at minimal risk of natural disasters.

In a country where peripheral regions have been neglected, this location is also strategically geopolitical for Jokowi. The move is expected to help redress economic disparity and development gaps between Indonesia’s most populous island, Java (where Jakarta is located), and the rest of the Indonesian archipelago.

The move is expected to help redress economic disparity and development gaps within Indonesia

In recent years, the need for a drastic rebalancing has become apparent: although Java is only the 4th largest island in Indonesia (out of 5 major ones), over half of Indonesians reside there and the region contributes to nearly 60% of GDP.  You don’t have to spend long in the comparatively underdeveloped Indonesian peripheries, to understand the resentment many have held for the ‘capital island’; the general sentiment has been one of feeling left behind. Jokowi likely hopes that the exodus of his government from Java to a more central location in Indonesia will be seen as a move towards national unity and redistribution.

Nevertheless, questions have been raised about the potential effectiveness of the project, expected to cost a whopping 33 billion US dollars. The new capital will be an administrative one (think Washington DC) and Jakarta will remain as the commercial and financial centre (think New York), meaning the overwhelming majority of Jakarta’s 12 million residents are unlikely to relocate. So how can Jokowi reasonably expect anything to change?

Could there be another reason to relocate? Is this new city really a symbolic move towards unity and redistribution in Indonesia, or could it instead be an escape plan for Indonesia’s government elite? Rather than fixing decades of poor urban planning and infrastructure in Jakarta, they appear to be abandoning their sinking, traffic plagued ship. It seems the everyday Jakartan Business worker may be left to pick up the pieces in the old capital, while Jokowi and his friends enjoy their new roost.

Image: Kent Clark via Flickr