The Scottish referendum will be a vote of the heart, not the head
by Al Russell
This summer marked the launch of both ‘Yes Scotland’ and ‘Better Together’, the campaigns for and against Scottish independence respectively and saw the start of a two-year war of attrition, in which nationalists and unionists will slug it out for votes.
Nationalists have sought to make the debate about party politics, crowbarring the word Tory into every mention of the unionist movement, in a desperate attempt to play on a deep-rooted hatred of the Conservatives in central Scotland, thanks to Thatcher’s economic policy in the 1980s. Unionists have taken an economic tack, focussing on the instability of an independent Scotland’s revenue flow.
However, they may both be wasting their time. This boils down to the fact that this is a referendum of the heart, not the head. Very few voters will change sides, no matter how effective either campaign is, because their beliefs about independence are a crucial part of their identity. Whichever side is genuinely right on the economic prospects of an independent Scotland, these arguments matter so much less to most voters than the total sovereign mutation of the country in which they live, for better or worse.
As a unionist Scot, I have followed the arguments put forward by either side and have been swayed by nothing the nationalists have offered up, while I’m sure that the SNP’s membership has equally sought to pick holes in the pro-British campaign.
You could tell me that an independent Scotland would be better off for the next hundred years than a Scotland in the UK and (assuming I believed you) I still wouldn’t vote for independence, because an independent Scotland isn’t my country. British Scotland is, for richer or poorer.
Often, the danger of referenda is that crucial, long term issues can be decided based on the whim of the country at a particular point in time, and on which side had a better campaign. This was the case in the 2004 referendum on an assembly for the North East of England. The ‘No’ campaign was very effective, hinging on the argument that yet another level of democracy – this is, one between local council and national level – was a pointless waste of money. I am convinced, however, that the Scottish independence referendum is unusual in this regard.
Britishness is a fundamental part of who many Scots are, to the same extent that it is an alien concept to many others. The timing of the vote is therefore an attempt by the SNP to take advantage of a sense of Scottishness in the year of the Glasgow Commonwealth Games and, in a horrible cliché, the 700th anniversary of the Battle of Bannockburn.
However, those who want to see it that way will be further turned off by this fact, seeing it as a crass insult to voters’ intelligence. This is symptomatic of the whole debate: everyone who cares about it makes of it what they want to, shaping the facts to fit their feelings, rather than the reverse.
Photograph from Hockadilly, on Flickr

