The Russian anti-war movement
By Anonymous
As of this article’s writing, Russian authorities have arrested 13,816 people for participating in anti-war demonstrations. There have been instances of police violence, torture at police stations and arrests of minors. How has the Russian anti-war movement evolved and why do protests remain limited?
Russian media and social nets flooded with anti-war statements from prominent writers, sports stars, musicians, and actors in the first days of the war. Open letters have been signed by scientists, medical workers, the largest NGOs, and even by graduates of the Moscow State Institute of International Relations that supplies workers for the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. A petition on change.org that demands to immediately stop the war with Ukraine has gathered 1 million signatures on March the 1st and continues to grow.
Government institutions were quick to react to this pressure by banning the few remaining independent media sources. Further introduced were criminal offences for anti-war statements and de facto policy for the severe mistreatment of street protesters. There have been public declarations condemning the war by several municipal councils but none of the members of the Russian parliament or any other high ranked official has expressed any anti-war sentiments. The most influential opposition radio station, Echo of Moscow, and the only independent political TV channel, Dozhd, have been forced to shut down.
Demonstrations started immediately after the entrance of the Russian army into Ukraine and people have been gathering to protest against the war almost every day ever since. However, these protests have not reached the size of demonstrations in many western capitals and around the globe. There is no simple explanation of why the level of protests is not as significant as one may expect. Still, the key factors that can be identified are the current state of the Russian opposition and the high personal cost of participation.
The cost of participation for each particular individual is very high
The Russian state has been consistently oppressing Russian opposition during the two decades of Putin’s rule. Opposition activists were banned from participating in elections, pushed to emigrate, jailed or even killed. In the year ramping up to the invasion, organizations of the leader of the Russian opposition, Alexey Navalny, were declared illegal and independent media’s activity was further restricted. Consequently, recent anti-war protests are to a large extent decentralized and by now operate without any substantial coordination.
Even more importantly, the cost of participation for each particular individual is very high. Almost 5 thousand people were arrested on countrywide protests on the 6th of March alone and a minimum of 34 protesters have received serious injuries. Police have been beating people with feet, used batons and electroshocks. Historically any physical confrontation with police is prosecuted as a major criminal offence. By now protesters get fines and administrative arrests.
According to the law passed by the Russian Duma (lower house of the Russian parliament) on March the 4th, any individual or organization can be prosecuted for the distribution of “fake information” about the activities of the Russian army. The same law states, that for “discrediting” Russian military forces one can receive criminal charges ranging from a tough financial penalty to 15 years in prison. In light of the recent publications of evidence of systematic torture in Russian prisons, the risk of participating in anti-war protests is high and real.
In this political climate anti-war movement emerges from the activity of distinct remaining media, civil rights and political organizations. Some operate from abroad and some stay in Russia, encouraging resistance to the war. Although peaceful protestors contribute to the positive image of Russian civil society from the western perspective, if the character and the volume of protests do not change, Putin’s regime is unlikely to change its tactic of violence and fear.
Image: Barbara Brundage via Flickr

