The rout of royalty: the finest FA Cup giant-killings
By Ollie Dickens
Ahh the magic of the FA Cup! The visualisation of multimillionaire “Prima donnas” clutching 3G turf, seeing a contractual bonus vanish before their eyes at the hands of a team of greengrocers never fails to satisfy. The Macclesfield miracle reminded us of the FA Cup’s beauty, and they can be proud of their work in seeing Marc Guehi and soon Oliver Glasner scatter, probably to escape the ghosts of the cataclysmic defeat.
As an FA Cup shock this was especially satisfying, seeing the FA cup winners humiliated. Yet Crystal Palace have not been the only offenders, with the world’s greatest cup competition seeing many greater teams die at the sword of lower league heroes. Let’s have a look at some of the best, shall we!
Sutton 2 – 1 Coventry (1989)
On a cold January afternoon, 8000 fans squeezed into the 6000 capacity Gander Green Lane keen to see the former history teacher Barrie Williams lead fifth-tier Sutton to a giant-killing. They would be forgiven for not expecting much, facing (in today’s money) a £135-million team largely similar to the Coventry team victorious in the 1986-1987 FA Cup.
Yet despite scoring in the 52nd minute, Coventry were stunned by two Sutton goals either side of half time. Keeper error accounted for Tony Rains’s goal in the 42nd minute, but it was the thunderous Matthew Hanlan volley from a short corner cross which sent the Sutton ultras to cloud nine.
Holding on to secure the victory, Sutton’s win “distilled the essence of Cup Magic”, according to The Observer’s Ronald Atkin. Yet what truly emblemised the Cup Magic was Sutton forward Hanlan’s enforced afternoon off from his bricklaying trade to wax lyrical of the achievement on the Terry Wogan chat show.
Who cares if they got trashed 8-0 by Norwich in the 4th round! In beating Coventry, they would remain, until 2013, the most recent non-league team to win against a top-flight outfit, a statistic ensuring Sutton’s deserved entry onto this list.
Wrexham 2 – 1 Arsenal (1992)
This 1991-1992 3rd round fixture was the definitive best versus worst clash of the titans. A far cry from today’s Hollywood stars, Wrexham rocked up having only survived relegation from the football league the year prior due to structuring changes.
Arsenal meanwhile were first-division champions but adorning a fabulously ugly leopard-skin kit. However, it was the cat-like Welsh outfit which humbled the seven-England international strong Arsenal on this cold January day.
The first half was usual enough, with future commentary royalty Alan Smith capitalising on a typically casual Paul Merson cross, giving the Gunners a 1-0 lead at half time. Yet Arsenal’s Dyche-like long ball tactics only succeeded until the 82nd minute when the ‘magic little man’ Mickey Thomas thundered a free kick past the despairing David Seaman.
Only two minutes later, Wales was sent into wonderland when Wrexham number 10 Steve Watkin pounced on a fumble (à la Nathan Lyon) by Tony Adams to poke home and secure a 2-1 victory.
Fortunes would quickly reverse themselves, with Thomas arrested 8 days later for his role in a counterfeit money scam, whilst Arsenal would secure FA Cup silverware the following year. However, nothing can ever take away Wrexham’s hope and Guinness fuelled humiliation of the mighty Gunners on this famous day.
Bradford 4 – 2 Chelsea (2015)
The 2014/2015 FA cup arrived under a cloud of criticism, with the competition increasingly being seen as a competition disguised as a mockery. Yet the giant-killing of Chelsea by Bradford, better known for producing world-cup winning cricketers Johnny Bairstow and Adil Rashid, restored the oft-stated magic of the oldest cup competition.
A Chelsea squad adorning a valuation of over £400m, along with over 600 international caps, met the ‘Bantams’, featuring only one player, James Hanson, not bought on a free transfer.
At first, Chelsea were sitting pretty with Gary Cahill and Brazilian midfielder Ramires ensuring a 2-0 lead. Having only lost a 77-unbeatan run at Stamford Bridge the year prior, José Mourinho looked to be extending his stranglehold at home. Yet the Bantams would not be silenced.
A wonderful Jon Stead effort pulled a goal back, yet the last fifteen minutes saw a Chelsea collapse even England’s test cricket team would be proud of. Filipe Morais silenced SW London with his 75th minute equalizer, before strikes from Andy Halliday and Mark Yeates secured a seemingly unbelievable 4-2 victory.
Not even the presence of World-cup winning Cesc Fabregas could prevent the ‘Bantams’ becoming the first third tier team to score four goals at Chelsea’s home since 1912. Deserving winners of the Ronnie Radford Giant-Killers award, they would eventually fall at the Quarter Final hurdle, with Chelsea going on to win the Premier League. A proper giant-killing!
Image Credit: ConifersOfGnarnia

