The risk of a 21st century Dust Bowl
By Emma Thomson
Key food crops may be reduced by up to 65% if an event similar to the 1930s Dust Bowl in the US occurs in the 21st century. Through modelling the impacts of dust storms similar in magnitude to those of the 1930s, it has been found that our crops would be hugely affected. In a world 2ÂşC warmer there is likely to be a 65% reduction in the production of maize, and such warming is likely to occur if current predictions are correct, even after the Paris Climate Summit. If the dust-bowl phenomenon were to occur this year, maize production would still be reduced by up to 40%, which would have a huge impact on the global food market.
Joshua Elliot, who conducted the research at the University of Chicago, admitted that the likelihood of such an event occurring in the 21st century was relatively low, as precipitation patterns are different to those of the 1930s. However, the temperature extremes witnessed during the Dust Bowl are relatively similar to modern temperature extremes, meaning the likelihood of such an event occurring increases again.
There are some crops which are more vulnerable to the changing temperatures, particularly maize and soy, which means that regardless of a dust-bowl like event occurring, these crops may suffer as a result of Climate Change. Such crops are also increasingly vulnerable because the crops are often concentrated within one region, such as the wheat belt in the US. If there is an extreme weather event in a location in which a large proportion of the crops are grown, and the crops in that region are wiped out, then there will be a huge reduction in the supply of said crop. Not only will this cause a dramatic increase in food price, but it will also have the potential to cause widespread food shortage.
Separating the crops across different areas, and thus reducing their concentration, will reduce the likelihood of extreme weather having such an impact on the food supply system. Â With this in mind, it is important to note that while the US is a prominent site of maize production, as is the China Plain, the likelihood of both being affected at the same time is relatively small.
Another way in which the security of our food resources may be maintained is through the use of genetically modified (GM) crops. Of course, there are many ethical issues surrounding GM crops, but their application is important within this context. Currently, only one type of GM crop can be commercially grown within the European Union: pest-resistant Maize; although this is mainly used for animal fodder, No GM crops are commercially grown within the UK. However, this may be set to change as in 2015 the EU declared that individual countries could decide whether they would commercially grow GM crops, which makes them a plausible component of the world’s, or at least the EU’s, food resources.
GM crops are already available in other countries, including the US and India, with the majority of US corn being genetically modified. Despite this availability, Scotland and Wales have already ruled out the possibility of growing GM crops within their borders. Even in the UK, some products are sold which contain genetically modified ingredients, although this is mainly in cooking oils.
Despite the controversy surrounding GM crops in the UK and Europe, they would have some advantages over normal crops if a dust-bowl type phenomenon were to occur. If the crops’ genes were modified so as to become resistant to drought and heat, then the crops would have an increased capacity to withstand the impacts of dust storms. This would increase food security during the phenomenon, and hopefully would help to keep the food costs down. However it should be considered that genetically modified crops are expensive to create and implement initially, and thus may not be cost-effective for farmers and producers, despite their capacity to increase food security.
It is clear that, although unlikely, the impacts of a phenomenon similar to that of the 1930s US Dust Bowl would be pronounced across the globe. Despite only physically damaging the crops grown in the region where the dust-bowl were to occur, this would have knock-on effects for crop resources all over the world. It would increase the pressure placed upon the remaining crops, and thus cause the price of the remaining crops to increase as demand grew. Not only would this cause the aforementioned economic impacts, but also potentially cause food shortages which could impact people all over the world as the key crops would be affected and food insecurity increased.
If a dust-bowl like event were to occur, perhaps the role of genetically modified crops within the food chain would have to be reconsidered, in order to reduce the impact of the food shortage on the world population. With all of this in mind, it is extremely important that the national governments of the world focus on maintaining the commitments they made regarding the fight against Climate Change at COP21, as the impacts of a dust storm would be considerably reduced if the predicted 2 degrees Celsius warming is avoided.
Photograph:Â A dust storm approaches Stratford, Texas, in 1935 /Â NOAA George E. Marsh Album via Wikimedia Commons
