The Return of Percy Jackson

By Sam Little

It is now thirteen years since The Last Olympian was released, and Rick Riordan has announced a sixth part to the immensely popular series: The Chalice of the Gods, on sale September 2023. Since then, it has become nothing short of a cultural phenomenon- the original series alone having sold more than 180 million copies worldwide. Its influence equally extends beyond the literary: an assortment of merchandise, a musical remake, even a fully-immersive Camp Half-Blood experience (children only, I checked!). It’s safe to say that its scope is astronomical. 

My first reaction on hearing this was one of extreme excitement, yet I could not dispel the anxiety that accompanied it. Explaining his resumption of the series, Riordan suggested it “would not only be fun to write,” but would simultaneously “promote the [upcoming Disney+] show.” Despite his assertions of the contrary, returning to a collection so long after its conclusion appears an effort to milk the series for its evident financial potential. Indeed, the novel was originally conceived as a means of convincing Disney to go ahead with the remake. 

…Returning to a collection so long after its conclusion appears an effort to milk the series for its evident financial potential

Though many readers were disappointed by Percy’s reduced relevance in the Heroes of Olympus series, it nevertheless felt like a logical conclusion. Unfortunately, exorbitant profits often outweigh aesthetic or sentimental evaluations; we can all picture sequels that should never have been made. Unlike the first five, Chalice is no “world-ending adventure,” “just a day in the life of a demigod.” Though Riordan maintains the mythological foundation, fitting quests in with Percy’s college application, the plot feels comparatively underwhelming. The novel might provide closure for its devoted fanbase, but closure is the antithesis of what brought the series to cultural prominence. It is exactly because the novel is incomplete that it attains timelessness, perpetuated through the reader’s imagination. By adjoining this work, it imposes canonical definitude, which may contravene the envisioned storyline constructed over the decade-long gap. If Chalice significantly alters character perception, it could prove traumatic to the rosy bubble of childhood the series is enshrined within.

Content aside, there are literary issues that must be considered. Riordan contends not only with the temporal gap, but furthermore with perceptual notions popularised by the series’ sheer renown. Highly active on social media himself, it seems unlikely that his vision hasn’t been at least subtly altered by the influx of fan opinion; thus, the novel may not be faithful to his original vision, but rather adhere to a desired conclusion imposed upon him. It is also notable that Riordan has begun to experiment artistically: Daughter of the Deep (2021) tackles science fiction rather than mythology, 2023 will see his first collaborative work, whilst he is venturing into the cinematographic field with Disney. Adopting his writing style of seventeen years prior not only seems immensely difficult but incongruous with his artistic progression. Nevertheless, Riordan asserts that the style will remain unperturbed; though Percy “sounds a bit older,” he wants “the books to continue being suitable for middle grade readers.” Riordan thereby risks alienating both his older reader, who could struggle with the adolescent tone, and younger fans, who cannot relate to the concerns of adult life. For how could Percy Jackson compare to the intricacies of Shakespeare or Joyce? And who wants to read a story where things don’t go boom boom?

Riordan thereby risks alienating both his older reader, who could struggle with the adolescent tone, and younger fans, who cannot relate to the concerns of adult life.

It must be noted, however, that Riordan has placed Percy at the forefront of everything he has subsequently written. Even if Percy is not the central figure, many of Riordan’s novels are foregrounded in his universe, whilst he appears even in other mythological worlds. Though Riordan’s task is unenviable (and perhaps impossible), it seems he could not be better placed to undertake it. Such is his familiarity with this world, it is perhaps not an effort of returning to a former universe, but rather extracting again from one he never left. He certainly betrays no concerns about it, comparing it to “putting on your most comfortable pair of jeans.” 

However successful this may prove, I’d be lying to say I’m not desperately excited. Once more, I shall be immersed in the series that has brought me so much joy, the series that I will be reading until I can read no longer.

Image Credit: Anna Kuptsova

https://www.dunelm.org.uk/donations/palatinate