The resurgence of dystopian fiction: 1984 and The Handmaid’s Tale

By Lucy Godridge 

Following the annus horribilis that was 2016, George Orwell’s dystopian classic Nineteen Eighty-Four has returned to the best seller lists. Over 67 years after it was first published it seems more relevant than ever, from the rise of Ministry of Truth-esque ‘alternative facts’ to fears of increased government surveillance infringing our right to privacy. However, the most pronounced parallels between Nineteen Eighty-Four and the society in which we live reveal themselves if we read ‘the Party’ and ‘Big Brother’ as a metaphor for the media rather than the government. Thanks to technology, and the fact that our ‘screens’ are so embedded in today’s world (as the screens in Nineteen Eighty-Four are), the media has an unprecedented ability to control every aspect of our lives. It controls our language, with the universally understood emojis taking the place of the ‘newspeak’ of Orwell’s world. It controls what we find out about current affairs and the world around us, and our opinions on these things, and when it changes its mind we are somehow meant to forget that the opposite view was ever espoused, such as the change in attitude towards refugees in the Mediterranean in the Daily Mail – very reminiscent of Oceania’s shifting alliances in Nineteen Eighty-Four. The media even dictates which political parties get into power and the policies they run, blurring the line between politics and the media to the point where a TV personality can be voted President of the United States. Most worryingly of all, it dictates what we think of ourselves, and who we think we should be, making ‘thoughtcrime’ an all too recognisable phenomenon.

But perhaps Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale is equally pertinent in terms of the parallels that can be drawn with current events. The novel is set in a dystopian future in which America has become a totalitarian theocracy, where the only role of women is procreation and housework, and any non-conformists are publicly executed. As with Nineteen Eighty-Four, although the world created in The Handmaid’s Tale is still a long way removed from present-day America, the issues that it discusses are at least as relevant today as when it was first published in 1985. The institutional oppression and complete objectification of women in the novel, while clearly inspired by our not-so-distant past, could also be read as a terrifying warning of the potential consequences of electing a president who appears to view women as sexual objects at his personal disposal, and who mere weeks into his presidency sits in an office of men signing away women’s rights to autonomy over their reproductive organs. And while no one would argue that America is a theocracy quite yet, the recent persecution and scapegoating of Muslims, and presidential support for waterboarding does set those alarm bells ringing. Most alarmingly, The Handmaid’s Tale is an exploration of what happens when a society decides to prioritise attaining ‘freedom from’ anything perceived as a threat over ‘freedom to’ live life as you like. Fundamentally, The Handmaid’s Tale is a story about a government system exploiting xenophobia and fear of change to increase its control over people’s lives in the name of defence and protection, and as such, is sickeningly familiar to anyone following American politics.

Although perhaps what gives us greatest cause for concern when reading both of these novels is not how accurately they represent the societies in which we live, but the comparative ease with which our nations could reach that state. After all, the Conservative Party’s attacks on the Human Rights Act, or Donald Trump’s ‘Muslim Ban’ would make for excellent foreshadowing in a dystopian novel.

Photograph by Meesh via Flickr and Creative Commons