The rejection of female bishops is a national embarrassment
by Robert Parr
The Church of England’s recent decision to reject legislation that would have allowed clergywomen (or is it clergy people?) to become bishops has, in the words of Bishop Stephen Cottrell, risked it becoming a ‘national embarrassment’. Undoubtedly this decision has shown the Church to be divorced from the consensus reached by wider society on gender equality, but no one should be particularly surprised.
Just a cursory glance at the positions held by organized religion in what might be termed recent history reveals it to time and again have been spectacularly out of touch with the opinions and principles of modern society. This ranges from the absence of any condemnation of slavery from the Catholic Church before society itself undertook its abolition in the 1800s to the more recent opposition by the Church of England to gay clergymen. Indeed, even in the present day with its current stance against gay marriage, Dr Rowan Williams is right when he judges the Church to have been ‘willfully blind’ to ideas agreed upon by the rest of civilization.
Therefore it is clear that this is what happens when you reject the power of reason and civilized discourse to shape our society, in favour of the teachings of a Bronze Age mythology. The misogyny exhibited in the Bible may well have represented the best wisdom of its time, but to make judgements rooted in these theological principles today is fantastically regressive and morally absurd.
The debate over women’s right to equality of opportunity in employment and institutional sexism was first fully and perhaps most eloquently developed by John Stuart Mill in the mid-to- late 19th Century.
Through debate and legislation, the principle that women should have equal access to every position of institutional office and employment has been enshrined in our culture to such a degree that to even question it would seem to many absurd. To say then that the Church of England has shown itself to be ‘at the very least behind the times’ as culture secretary Maria Miller has done, is to put it lightly.
However morally backward this decision may seem to be, you may well ask what its significance for wider society actually is. Is the structure of the Church’s hierarchy not a private matter to be decided amongst themselves? Well, that would be the case if the Church were a private institution, but unfortunately it is not. This is not an organization which keeps its ideas and preachings confined to the closed walls of its congregations, but one which is inextricably linked to our political system.
This is not an obscure cult formed by a con man as is the case with Mormonism. The danger of the irrationality and backwardness that religion poses even to a society with an entrenched separation of church and state is illustrated by how Mitt Romney – a former bishop of a church staunchly against the ordainment of black people to its priesthood until 1978 – came dangerously close to becoming the ‘leader of the free world’ (his own definition of ‘free’ would be interesting to hear).
It is the Church of England, which remains un-separated from our own state, a Church for which our own monarch sits as the head, who although is no longer believed to be divinely appointed, is elected only by the lottery of birth.
It is also a Church which cannot refrain from contributing to our social and political discourse, and which believes itself to be a bastion of moral leadership. The implication of this recent decision against the ordainment of female bishops should be for us all to question the validity of its opinion on any other issue of significance.
If it is an institution incapable of agreeing to a principle so widely accepted by the rest of society as female equality, then what insight can it possibly offer on debates which are currently being contested, the conclusions of which will shape our future?
Furthermore, what wisdom can a regressive religion bring to discussions over the morality of using stem cells, or our interactions and potential conflicts with states in the Middle East that are subjugated to a far greater extent by religion than our own?
I hope that the way in which it has recently discredited itself makes the answer to that question obvious as the Church of England has become a national embarrassment. The sooner it becomes a national irrelevance the better.

