The real reason why fewer girls study physics

By Isobel Jones

The government’s social mobility commissioner Katharine Birbalsingh has been criticised for her “outdated” claims that fewer girls choose to study A level physics due to not wanting to do “hard maths”. In a session with the Commons Science and Technology Committee on diversity and inclusion in STEM, she told MPs that “physics isn’t something that girls tend to fancy.”

Birbalsingh, who was appointed Chair of the Social Mobility Commission in October 2021, also holds the position of headteacher at Michaela Community School in Wembley and has been dubbed the UK’s strictest headteacher. When questioned about the below-average percentage of female A level physics students at her own school, she said “I just think they don’t like it. There’s a lot of hard maths in there that I think they would rather not do.”

When asked to elaborate on why girls would be less likely to want to do hard maths than boys Birbalsingh – a Philosophy and Modern Languages graduate herself – responded “they say that that’s just a natural thing, I mean I don’t know, I can’t say, I’m not an expert at that sort of thing.”

She added, “We’re certainly not out there campaigning for more girls to do physics, we wouldn’t do that and I wouldn’t want to do that, because I don’t mind that there’s only 16% of them, I want them to do what they want to do.”

In 2021 nationally only 23% of physics A level students were female

According to WISE, a campaign encouraging inclusivity and equality for women in STEM in the UK, in 2021 nationally only 23% of physics A level students were female. In comparison to other STEM subjects, in the same year, girls made up 39% of maths students and 55% of chemistry students.

However, the lower number of girls choosing physics and maths does not reflect poor academic performance in these subjects, as last year over half of female maths and physics A level students achieved A or A* grades. This figure was even higher for girls studying further maths, with 78% of female students achieving an A or A*.

A report published by the Institute of Physics (IOP) in 2018 found that while 65% of girls have physics in their top four grades at GCSE, only 8% of these students choose physics A level. Furthermore, almost double the number of girls take A level biology when it wasn’t in their top four grades than physics when it was in their top four.

Reaching out to female physics students at Durham on why fewer girls choose to study physics highlighted issues with the culture surrounding the subject. A common view was the “real lack of female role models in physics,” as, while everyone knows Einstein and Newton, fewer students are taught about the work of female physicists such as Lise Meitner or Jocelyn Bell Burnell.

“In my first year, there was only one other woman and in my second year only me to around 17 boys”

Durham students also spoke about the damage done by traditional gender stereotypes as “working as a scientist or an engineer is often thought of as a male role so less women are encouraged to venture into the industry.”

Speaking of their own experiences while studying A level physics one Durham student said, “In my first year, there was only one other woman and in my second year only me to around 17 boys.”

She added “they had generated a hostile environment that many women who would be interested in physics or maths are often dejected by. I didn’t feel very welcome in my own college. Which shouldn’t be the case all because of your gender. I often felt I had to work above and beyond to get exceptional grades just to be considered one of them.”

The IOP has responded to Birbalsingh’s comments by condemning her “outdated” views and calling for “a united effort to encourage a range of youngsters to take up the subject.” IOP Deputy Chief Executive, Rachel Youngman, commented: “We need to listen to the experiences of young people before making assumptions which can further perpetuate the challenges they face in doing physics. Young people themselves, including many girls, tell us they face barriers to studying physics because of who they are rather than their ability.”

Image: thisisengineering via Unsplash