The Razor Blade
Why Channel 4 continues to waste so much time attempting to rejuvenate the careers of has-beens in the terrible Big Brother is beyond me, especially when they are the channel behind this century’s finest television creation, the dinner party reality show.
The re-launch of Come Dine with Me in its original student primetime one-a-day format is an exciting step for the airwaves, and a perfect canapé before Home and Away.
However the real joy this January is to be found in the second ‘series’ of C4’s Great British Food Fight. This year we see Heston, Hugh, Jamie, and Gordon tackle the nations culinary dilemmas armed only with pipettes, shotguns, shouting, and barbecue tongs.
The big question is who will come out on top? And more importantly who deserves to?
All four of the competitors are men, all of them very successful, all of them very different. Heston Blumenthal is one of the world’s best chefs, his three Michelin star restaurant The Fat Duck has won countless awards including world restaurant of the year in 2005.
With his bald head, thick rimmed glasses and passion for gadgets and science Heston is the typical British geek. If he wasn’t cooking you could imagine him deep in his shed with only Warhammer and toy trains as company.
In one of his previous shows he encouraged viewers to make aero-style chocolate in their kitchens using a Hoover, a vacuum bag and an empty biscuit tin. Here lies the problem, I doubt that anyone tried that recipe for disaster in their own kitchen, just like the staff at little chef didn’t want to try his recipes in theirs. His cooking is too clinical, too cold, and too perfect to relate too.
Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall on the other hand is so homely he already has a toothbrush in the cup by the sink. He is posh, he is eccentric, his kids (Oscar, Freddy and Chloe) will probably one day go to Hild Bede, but he is has passion in wheelbarrow loads, and he is messy in his kitchen.
Some might think that his love for chickens is bordering on the obsessional, and his expectation that everyone can afford free-range organic poultry wildly optimistic but on the whole Whittingstall talks sense and cooks food you’d want to eat if you were brave enough to cook it. Apart from the human placenta pâté, that was just plain wrong.
Gordon Ramsay’s personal life aside, the Scottish chef is an impressive man. A professional sportsman turned professional chef, wrinkled, battered but unnervingly handsome, angry, explicit but with spine tingling charm.
Disappointingly Ramsay’s television success does not tend to be based on what goes on the plate. Ramsay sees cooking as a business and it comes across in his incessant competitiveness, with other celebrities in the recipe challenges, and more toe curlingly with his own ego in Hells Kitchen.
Gordon has shown the public what you have to be like to be the best in the world, shown us what a professional kitchen is actually like, but in doing so he has been a total bastard. He isn’t cooking to feed you and your family; he is cooking for himself, and his bank account. Done.
Finally there is the naked chef. Unjustly criticised in the last edition of Palatinate for food fascism Jamie Oliver is far from a tortellini Mussolini.
With passion and enthusiasm, blended with tremendous skill, Jamie, like it or not, has changed the way that this country consumes food. His Rotherham based ‘pass it on’ campaign may have received criticism, and failed to have the effect that was desired, but the principle demonstrated has been working with deliciously positive results worldwide for 10 years.
Fundamentally ‘Pass it on’ underpins everything Oliver has achieved. With School Dinners, his phenomenal charitable work at the 15 foundation, cook books, TV shows, and in the superb Jamie’s Italian restaurant chain, it is evident that his unbounded energy and generosity is what makes these ventures not just a success, but a valuable asset to society. Jamie has made a difference.
The man is not telling us what to eat, he is asking us to think about what we eat, and at the same time empowering us with the culinary skills to be able to choose what we put in our mouth. Without any of the knowledge that Jamie, or others like him, feed us with we are slaves to the supermarkets. We would have to eat what they prepare for us.
Iceland would be determining our diet, and I can assure you, that is not a positive step. Giving freedom, choice, and empowerment through knowledge is not fascism.
Life is about choices. And learning to cook is just a way of giving yourself more choices, and hopefully better choices for life. I am what I eat, and because of that I will not be having cherry drops, mince pies and Pringles on my plate for dinner.
