The Proust effect

By Daniel Stephens

Sometimes, on certain brisk autumn mornings in Durham, I am flooded with images of a younger me. I do not know whether it is the temperature, the breeze, or the sun, but for some reason, in their combination, I am transported to a morning in my childhood. I cannot tell you which exact morning it reminds me of, and yet the present and past mornings begin to meld. I can see my younger self walking along with his backpack and parents in tow, walking alongside me. A visceral, nostalgic sensation, that crisp morning air seems to unlock a memory I had forgotten, letting me experience it once more. 

Proust describes memories as merely regret for a person, place, or moment. Trying to recall the past is futile because it is ‘hidden outside the realm of our intelligence and beyond its reach’

 Marcel Proust captures this ephemeral sensation of nostalgia in the opening of the first part of his monumental novel In Search of Lost Time. The novel opens with the Narrator reflecting on his limited memory of his childhood home, Combray, dominated by a singular, fragmentary memory. The Narrator describes his anguish when his mother’s routine nightly goodnight kiss would be interrupted by the visits of a family friend, Mr. Swann. It is the singularity and dominance of this image that killed the Narrator’s memory of Combray. That is, until the taste of the madeleine reveals the rest. Upon tasting the combination of tea and madeleine, the Narrator is instantly overcome with a mysterious sensation. Eventually, those sensations begin to crystallize as nostalgia, and the Narrator describes how the madeleine unlocks forgotten memories of Combray. For me, it was the sensations of the breeze and sunshine that brought a forgotten memory to the fore. For the Narrator, it was some tea and a madeleine. 

When reading Proust’s descriptions of the ‘powerful joy’ of this nostalgic sensation, it is easy to be in awe of the beauty of the madeleine, unearthing countless forgotten memories of the Narrator’s hometown. For Proust, however, the memories themselves are not the drivers of joy. Proust describes memories as merely regret for a person, place, or moment. Trying to recall the past is futile because it is ‘hidden outside the realm of our intelligence and beyond its reach’ and the ‘information it gives about the past preserves nothing of it’. This type of voluntary memory is what created the Narrator’s narrow memory of his hometown before the madeleine, and how the Narrator engages with those memories after being awakened by the madeleine. The Narrator’s joy does not come from these memories. 

The full Combray of his childhood begins to unfold, revealing the forgotten vibrancy of its locales and characters as do the petals of a flower

The Narrator likes to imagine the past as sustained in inanimate objects. The past is dead to us until, by chance, we stumble upon these objects and reanimate the memories so that they ‘have overcome death, and return to live with us’. The madeleine is one such object. Upon its taste, the Narrator is instantly overwhelmed by its ‘delicious pleasure’. The Narrator struggles to put into words this powerful sensation. With successive sips of the tea and taste of the madeleine, the effect weakens, awaking less and less of that moving sensation. Only after deliberate attempts to reach the memories hinted by this overwhelming sensation does the image of an identical moment surprisingly emerge: another madeleine, eaten as a child in Combray. From this, the full Combray of his childhood begins to unfold, revealing the forgotten vibrancy of its locales and characters as do the petals of a flower. 

Only after a simultaneous process of searching within himself for the cause of this sensation and the creation of the attached memory does this powerful feeling reveal itself as nostalgia. The memories are a pleasant surprise, a mental reaction to the sensation awoken by the tea and madeleine, but the ‘powerful joy’ the Narrator experiences is found in the sensation of nostalgia, not the memories. This sensation ‘made the vicissitudes of life unimportant […], its disasters innocuous, its brevity illusory,’ only comparable to the passions of love. He had momentarily ‘ceased to feel […] mediocre, contingent, mortal’. This moment of nostalgia had broken the Narrator out of the confines of his life, its obligations, its rules, its incessant forward march. In that moment, the past and the present blurred, briefly freeing the Narrator. In In Search of Lost Time, Proust’s narrator finds meaning not in the content of his memories but in the act of reliving what was once dead. In those brief brushes against objects of the past, the Narrator’s linear perception of life breaks, simultaneously experiencing past and present. Unleashed by the taste of a madeleine, the Narrator basks in nostalgia’s unexpected and sweet embrace. 

As I graduate, leaving the last traces of my childhood in the past, uncertain when I will see many friends or eat another mid-seminar Cooplands sausage roll again, it is these moments of unexpected nostalgia that I can look forward to. However mundane the memory, Proust’s description of such a nostalgic sensation promises a momentary sublime freedom, in which the past and present walk side-by-side. 

Image: Benjamin Smith via Wikimedia Commons.