The price of perfection: Hollywood’s diet culture

By Tami Falope

The Golden Age of Hollywood spanning over the late 1920s to the 1960s was one of glamour, allure and pomp. It created some of cinema’s most iconic beauties from Marilyn Monroe to Judy Garland. The image depicted was one of desirability, excess and abundance for those in it. Where the narrative shifts, however, is what is exposed when we peer beyond the shiny exterior, and into what is contained in its’ shadows. What is revealed? A world that so strictly and mercilessly defined what it meant to be a desirable or successful woman. A world that set up laws policing their bodies, which were symbols of their worth.

The classic cinema optics and early lighting techniques of the Golden Age often widened a person’s features, giving rise to the famous adage that “the camera puts on 10 pounds”. This helped justify cycles of verbal and psychological abuse. The pressure and deprivation women felt can be seen through some of the following examples, importantly this isn’t even the worst of it.

Their bodies were watched objects to perfect; images to uphold

The 18-day Hollywood diet gained popularity among film industry celebrities in the late 1920s, spreading through magazine columns and chain letters like the plague – but disguised as a “fix” for women who dared to exist at their natural bodyweight. The goal was to eat a third of the suggested calorie intake to remain healthy. 

The Lucky Strike diet – ‘Reach for a Lucky instead of a sweet’, encouraged reaching for a cigarette as a way to curb appetite and maintain the slim ‘flapper’ silhouette of the 1920s.

The use of appetite-suppressing drugs in cases such as Frances Farmer’s. She began taking amphetamines shortly after arriving in Hollywood due to intense paranoia over gaining weight, which eventually fuelled her highly publicised mental health and substance struggles. 

Judy Garland suffered notorious abuse under studio heads, including Louis B. Mayer, who cruelly referred to her as a ‘fat little pig with pigtails’ to pressure and shame her into losing weight for film roles. She was placed on severe, restrictive diets that typically consisted of little more than black coffee, chicken soup or broth, lettuce and cottage cheese, and of course, forced smoking, 

Through food restriction and regulation, women were also placed against each other. For example, ‘lose weight or we will find another girl’, were the words used as warning to actress Marie Provost, who was already thin but forced into a desperate cycle of starvation. Not, ‘work on your lines,’ or ‘show more dedication to the art.’ Simply lose weight. Or a thinner woman will take your place. 

‘There is no more satisfaction than walking in a room knowing that no one can say, “she’s letting herself slip”.’ Joan Crawford’s statement from a 1951 interview so strikingly epitomises the mindset many women were burdened with. Their bodies were watched objects to perfect; images to uphold. In an industry that celebrated their talent, women’s professional worth could nevertheless be reduced to something as arbitrary as a number on the scales.

Between these diets, women were suffering immunity decline, severe malnutrition, exhaustion, fainting, muscle wasting, and other complications from weight-loss drug use. It is sorrowful that there wasn’t a cultural rejection of this constant striving and dieting, for acknowledgement of the fact that this simply wasn’t biologically or emotionally healthy for women. Or for any human. There is striking irony in the fact that, the leading women of the Golden Age inhabited a world of unimaginable abundance yet were expected to live with a scarcity and deprivation that their level of wealth should have rendered unnecessary. They were surrounded by luxury but taught to deny themselves one of life’s most elementary pleasures – eating. Their luxury became what trapped them.

The leading women of the Golden Age inhabited a world of unimaginable abundance, yet were expected to live with a scarcity and deprivation that their level of wealth should have rendered unnecessary

Therefore, the Hollywood world, and those who led it, placed women at a fork in the road, with two choices: deprive yourself to stay in this glamorous world, or maintain a healthy relationship with food and nutrition but lose prospects, opportunities, or any chance of making it. Which path would they choose? The way to the spotlight was to suffer in the darkness, and the way to be glamourous was to endure anguish. If we look at the state of Hollywood today, where an actress’s body continues to attract as much attention as her skill and performance, one cannot help but ask: has Hollywood truly progressed from its past, or merely learned to disguise it?

Not, ‘work on your lines,’ or ‘show more dedication to the art.’ Simply lose weight. Or a thinner woman will take your place

Illustration: Grace, Indigo Illustrations team