The price of ownership: is the Premier League losing its soul?

By Theo Hallsworth 

Yet again, football owners causing chaos have been plastered across the sports pages this season. From legal threats to poor decision making, owners and ownership groups have become impossible to ignore, for better or for worse.  

Recent tensions at Aston Villa, Manchester United and Nottingham Forest have exposed the growing divide between the people who own the clubs and the people who support them. Football has always been a business, but the increasing visible role of owners raises questions over who should come first – owners or fans? 

Following critical comments made by Jamie Carragher, Aston Villa’s chairman threatened legal proceedings against the pundit. This is a worrying sign. Should we now expect pundits to face legal action from clubs simply for stating their opinions? This latest incident points to a bigger issue in the modern game – the growing influence of owners and the extent to which their egos shape the clubs they run. 

From legal threats to poor decision making, owners and ownership groups have become impossible to ignore, for better or for worse

At Manchester United, the arrival of INEOS and Jim Ratcliffe was supposed to usher in a new era. After years of frustration with the Glazer family, fans were desperate for change. When INEOS acquired a minority stake in February 2024 and took over football operations, Ratcliffe promised to end instability and to challenge for the title by 2027/28. Today, those promises look increasingly unlikely.  

Since taking over, INEOS have overseen managerial change, staff cuts, and ticket price increases. Fan protests and public disagreements between players and board members have done little to suggest that United are moving in the right direction. Not all of United’s problems can be blamed on INEOS. They inherited a club with deep cultural and structural issues and do not hold majority ownership. However, the decisions they have made have only further fueled discontent. Cutting staff perks, hiking ticket prices, and failing to implement a clear sporting direction have left fans wondering what INEOS are trying to achieve. Many of the difficult financial decisions may have been unavoidable, but there is a difference between making hard choices and making supporters feel like an inconvenience. 

Nottingham Forest is another club with an ownership issue. Since taking over in 2017, Evangelos Marinakis has overseen Forest’s return to the top flight and ended a thirty-year absence from European football. On results alone, his ownership model is one many would envy. However, Marinakis’ personality has consistently overshadowed the club itself. His touchline confrontations with managers, public legal disputes, and highly visible involvement have made him a divisive figure.  

In 2025, Forest benefitted from UEFA’s decision to exclude Crystal Palace from the Europa League over multi-club ownership rules, after Marinakis reportedly raised concerns. The dispute resurfaced in August when Marinakis filed a defamation lawsuit against Palace, after supporters displayed a banner depicting the Forest owner holding a gun to Morgan Gibbs-White’s head. Of course, Marinakis is entitled to defend his reputation, but these incidents highlight how drama surrounding an owner can come to dominate conversations about their club. When the person in charge becomes bigger than the club they’re supposed to serve, something has gone wrong. 

When the person in charge becomes bigger than the club they’re supposed to serve, something has gone wrong

Yet owners are not all inherently bad. Brighton demonstrates what ownership can look like when ego is pushed aside, and the club’s success is prioritised. Under Tony Bloom, the Seagulls have built a sustainable model centered around developing young talent, data-led recruitment, and selling players for significant fees to fund their progress. Rather than chasing instant success, Bloom has prioritised creating a clear identity and a coherent sporting strategy all without alienating the fan base. Brighton currently sits at the top end of the table, beating wealthier rivals such as Arsenal on a much smaller wage bill, illustrating how effective this approach can be. The model is not flawless, but it highlights that commercial interests and sporting success need not be opposed. Good ownership should be custodial and about building something that can thrive beyond the owners.  

Is ownership causing the Premier League to lose its soul? Not necessarily, but there are warning signs. Investment and ambition are not the problems. Football needs owners willing to spend and plan for the future. The issues arise when egos and financial priorities take precedence over the clubs themselves. An owner can buy a club, change its manager, and raise ticket prices, but they cannot buy the supporters who have made clubs what they are or the history that has existed long before they arrived. This is what makes football different to any other business. A club’s value cannot be measured on a balance sheet alone. Owners will come and go; value will rise and fall, but the clubs and their fans remain. The Premier League is not yet losing its soul because of owners, but too many owners seem to have forgotten what makes football worth investing in. 

Image: Egghead06 via Wikimedia Commons