The Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood: ‘deadening’ or captivating?
I first encountered the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood (PRB) when I watched the BBC mini-series, ‘Desperate Romantics’, which focused around the lives of this elusive group of artists. Struck by the dynamism of the characters I was presented with and perhaps rather obnoxiously identifying with their rebellion against the preconceived notions of art during the time (I was still a self-important teenager back then) I was instantly captivated.
After greater exploration I found painters who drew inspiration from distant and mythical times, their subjects being figures such as Helen of Troy, Joan of Arc and Shakespeare’s Ophelia. As a Classics and English student I took great interest in these works of art which seemed to capture the essence of many of the characters that I’d studied and empathised with.
However, I also discovered that the pre-Raphaelites are vehemently looked down upon by many critics; their work is seen as garish and often lewd, their colours too vivid, their subjects too base. Germain Greer wrote an article on the Brotherhood which stated that the only thing desperate about the group was their “truly bad art” and Laura Cumming sees their art as “deadening” due to its literal nature. I however, would disagree.
When I visited the PRB exhibition at the Tate Britain over the Christmas holidays I did not become the “zombie” that Cumming predicted I would morph into. Yes, it is true that this group of painters all have a similar style and that the symbolism within their works is often strikingly, almost crudely, obvious, however I do not think that this is what is important about the movement.
What stood out to me most was how each painting comes across as nostalgic for a distant time of melodrama, in which saints and sinners were punished accordingly. Within the context of the Industrial, Victorian age in which these pictures were created one can see artists craving more flamboyance within life and less of the grey monotony of a new society centred around factory work.
It is obvious that the Brotherhood lack the technical ability of the painters that they admired – Titian and Botticelli for example – however their almost primitive style has a certain charm in it for me. At the exhibit I knew that I wasn’t being presented with artistic mastery but what I was seeing was a group of artists attempting to provide an escape from normality and I found that equally enthralling. Even though the art was harking back to the past it was ironically seen as radical by contemporaries due to its imaginative, dreamlike quality and it still remains intensely theatrical with its extravagant costumes serving to truly transport the onlooker to another world. Whether the past that the PHB were trying to portray was truly how the painters imagined is debatable, but their idealistic view of what had come before is endearing.
Therefore, if you place value on art solely for the technical ability of the artist in creating something lifelike or beautiful the Pre-Raphelite Brotherhood may not be for you. If, however, you want to be immersed in a world of myth and high drama, in which anything is possible, I’d look further into this truly original group of painters.
Image: Ophelia by John Everett Millais, flickrID:deflam

