The Pope's interference in secular politics has gone too far

Pope Benedict XVI’s recent foray into secular affairs concerning the Equality Bill, sparked outrage amongst gay and human rights campaigners last week. According to the Pope, the bill currently being pushed through parliament by Harriet Harman, “violates natural law” and diminishes the church’s right of freedom of religious expression. This is one voyage into secular politics too far from Rome.

The Pope urged Catholic bishops in England and Wales to fight the legislation with “missionary zeal”. I sincerely hope that they do not. This whole debacle highlights a few depressing things, the first being the arrogance of the Pope to assume that he has the right to enter into a secular political debate. Second, it raises questions as to whether religious institutions should be exempt from equality legislation in the first place and thirdly it makes the Pope’s state visit to the UK this year seem thoroughly pointless.

Father Christopher Whitehead, a priest from near Bristol, asserted that the Pope was not “dabbling in politics”. The absurdity and outright denial of the facts is not what is most remarkable. Father Whitehead went on to add that the Pope “has that role as a prophet and as a moral compass.” Yet the Pope has no mandate to interfere in secular politics (particularly those in this country): it is not and should not be his sphere.

Gay and human rights campaigners were quick to condemn the Pope’s discriminatory sentiment. Human rights campaigner Peter Tatchell believes that the Pope’s remarks represent a “coded attack on the legal rights granted to women and gay people”.

The Pope’s remarks have caused deep offence and controversy in the past, with this latest occurrence being a sad continuation of that trend. A visit to Africa in March 2009 was overshadowed by Pope Benedict’s claim that the distribution of condoms in Africa increases the problem of HIV/AIDS.

Freedom is a deeply subjective thing. The Pope’s notion of ‘freedom of religious expression’ directly curtails homosexuals’ (and women’s) freedom to any kind of employment. Especially considering the absence of doctrinal unanimity amongst Catholics over this contentious issue, it seems foolhardy to take heed of the Pope’s opinions of the Equality Bill. Labour MEP Stephen Hughes hit the nail on the head: “As a Catholic, I am appalled by the attitude of the Pope. Religious leaders should be trying to eradicate inequality, not perpetuate it.”

Without delving too far into a debate of literally biblical proportions, Jesus taught equality and love, which is surely incompatible with stopping women and homosexuals becoming Bishops. I find it almost impossible to reconcile Father Whitehead’s belief that “the Pope is trying to uphold true freedom”, with some of the comments Pope Benedict has made regarding homosexuality in the past.

Not only has he described homosexuality as a tendency towards “intrinsic moral evil”, he has called for pro-choice politicians to be denied communion. Clearly the meaning of “true freedom” is synonymous with inequality and discrimination. The question remains: why are women and homosexuals unequal when it comes to entry into the priesthood?

The government has stated that the legislation only applies to religious institutions in the employment of non-religious jobs, as they are eager to avoid a fallout with Rome. I would go further and argue that the Church should not, in any shape or form, be exempt from the laws of a given country. To secular society, religious institutions spiritual status does not in any way affect the fact that the church is an employer of people in the same way Tesco is.

The government’s rather timid response to the Pope’s remarks highlights much of the problems in current church-state relations. Labour obviously cannot risk a spat with the Roman Catholic Church, but I hold the view that if this kind of papal interference continues a harder line should be taken.

A Government Equalities Officer spokesman stated that “we believe everyone should have a fair chance in life and not be discriminated against” without openly condemning the Pope’s words. Thankfully, it seems as if the Pope’s comments will hold little political capital. However, the government is tied by the fact that the taxpayer footing the bill for the Pope’s state visit to the UK in September of this year.

I hate to be so populist as to talk of the ‘taxpayer’ as some kind of mythical being which is constantly evoked these days, but it is a legitimate concern. There is no reason why the state should be funding the visit of a man who is openly criticising the government’s equality legislation. If the Pope is likely to use the state visit as a platform to espouse his out of touch opinion that this country’s equality legislation is flawed, then what’s the point?

The trip is estimated to cost around £20million, money which I believe could be spent far better elsewhere. If the bill was paid for purely by Catholic taxpayers, I might have more sympathy, but it is not as if the Papacy is strapped for cash. Whereas, the public purse as everyone knows is frankly, well, knackered.

I firmly believe that in this country, the state and the church should continue to remain separate entities and Pope Benedict’s intervention is a worrying sign that he clearly holds the opposite view.