The politics of the televised election debates
By Matthew Kernaghan
In 2010 we saw the first ever live TV debates between the leaders of the three main political parties ahead of the UK general election. Across the 3 debates, throughout April, the leaders were posed questions on issues in domestic policy, foreign affairs and the economy. This change in the political process proved hugely popular with an electorate now very much in touch with social media and video, and therefore it had been assumed that similar such debates should now take place ahead of each general election. However the political landscape has changed.
Previously there was little consideration as to who the debates would be between. It was obvious; the leaders of the Conservatives, Labour and the Lib Dems, it didn’t seem appropriate to include anyone else or as if any particular party was being excluded. But five years later, the rise of both Nigel Farage’s UKIP and the Green Party, following their success in the European Elections last year, has left broadcasters with a huge dilemma. They must look to tread the fine line between appropriate representation for smaller parties while also ensuring that the debate is still meaningful without too many voices all trying to put forward their views.
Originally, when plans were unveiled, it was only UKIP, of the minor parties, that the broadcasters invited to the debates. They would take part in a four-way third debate after a one-on-one debate between Cameron and Miliband, followed by one involving Cameron, Miliband and Clegg. However, the Prime Minister stated he would not partake in any TV debates unless the Green Party was also involved as it would not be right to involve some minor parties and not others. Despite early rumours that they may “Empty Chair” Mr Cameron, it seems his demands have been met as plans were announced to involve seven political parties.
As well as the original three, under new plans, UKIP, the Green Party, the SNP and Plaid Cymru would also take part in two seven-way debates. The Lib Dems are particularly angered by the proposals as they believe that as a governing party they should have the ability to defend their work over the last Parliament in each of the three debates. It seems that it is going to be very difficult to keep everyone happy and compromises will have to be made somewhere. The debates are again planned for April so there is still plenty of time for discussion and negotiation as to who should and shouldn’t take part.
All the media attention appears to focus on the issue of who should be allowed to participate rather than whether we actually need the debates in the first place. Originally, it would appear a brilliant idea to put the leaders of the main parties head-to-head in front of the nation discussing topics that will no doubt dominate their election campaigns and be at the forefront of voters’ minds. Yet, if we were to take a step back and look at how useful they actually are it may present a different picture.
In practice, in the modern world of social media, 24 hour news and instant opinion polls, the debates can quickly become more about the various sound-bites or gaffes which create the headlines rather than the actual policies behind them. It may descend into more of a battle of media image and public speaking rather than intellectual and progressive political discussion.
Such debates equally make the incumbent prime minister vulnerable to attacks from populist insurgents such as Farage. In some sense this was shown in 2010 with Clegg’s success. This then must make us consider whether David Cameron is trying to avoid the TV debates purely on the grounds of fair representation or whether there is something more cynical to his stance. On the other hand it could be suggested that Miliband is keen to avoid having the Greens present, and was therefore happy with the original debates plan, as he may see their left-wing populism as a threat. There is undoubtedly a large amount of politics involved within what will happen as regards the TV debates; who is represented, for how many of the debates and if there will be an ‘empty chair’. Nevertheless, any sort of open political debate can only be good for increasing participation levels and electoral turnout.
Photograph: The Guardian

