The ‘politics of offence’ has gone too far!

By Shaun Sharkey
One of the lingering perceptions around the world of the English people is that we are all rather polite. Now, I’m not quite sure just how true this is. In my limited experience of foreign countries I have never noticed any great difference in manners. In fact, I even found the United States a kind, welcoming and civil place, despite all the prior insistence that it was populated by ‘grass-chewin’, spittin’ hicks’. Yet my international friends assure me: England is a strangely well-mannered country. Who am I to argue? At any rate it is at least something we can hope to live up to.
However, here in England one faces the opinion that we should scrap Prime Minister’s Questions on the grounds that it is ‘divisive’. What, by the way, is politics if it is not a division in opinion? One reads that we should turn universities into soggy ‘safe-spaces’ for the reason that life is remarkably provocative, or that we should not talk about the defects of religion, because to do so is ‘offensive’. It is then difficult to avoid the conclusion that things may have gone slightly too far in our conception of what can and cannot be said. Indeed, what is more rude and arrogant than asserting that ordinary people are unable to cope with serious debate?
Furthermore, aside from matters of decorum, what could be more dangerous? The wonderful Hermione Granger quite rightly says somewhere in Harry Potter that “Fear of a name only increases fear of the thing itself”, a statement that could quite easily be changed to, “Fear of a subject only increases fear of the issue itself”. The thrust of Miss Granger’s point is that the refusal to say unwelcome things simply creates paranoia and hysteria over the actual problems at hand, and that for this reason — she is, I believe, imploring someone to utter the name, ‘Voldemort’ — nothing must become unsayable or unthinkable.
Moving from the magical to the real, it can perhaps be said that this cult of civility is precisely one of the reasons political discourse within Western democracies is presently so sneering and crazed. In Britain we are familiar with the following dialectic: the ‘Civilising Crusaders’ ensure the ‘liberal elite’ do not say anything vaguely controversial, which then mollifies said elite, which then gives energy to the lunatic wings of our political parties who believe that the scheming and evil ‘overclass’ doesn’t want you to talk about immigration, psychopathic capitalists, aristocratic child abusers, the EUSSR, and so forth. The ‘politics of civility’, ironically, produces its own negation precisely because it deprives us of that much needed commodity in a democracy – honesty.
Indeed, the reason why ‘political outsiders’ like Jeremy Corbyn and Nigel Farage are doing so well here is because they are thought to be truth-speaking messiahs — which they are in the sense that they say what they think and, like all messiahs, are invariably wrong. This is the consequence of politeness to the point of asphyxiation; strange folk gain a lot of power and influence.
It seems that the only way out of this whole mess is to — now, isn’t this a grand idea — speak your mind. One of the reasons the United States is the most successful and pluralistic democracy in the world is because it enforces the right to free speech. This is the reason we find their news programmes so crass, because we instantly recognise people who are not governed, like we are, by psychic anxieties about other people’s feelings. The closest person we have to an American amongst our commentariat is, oddly, the rather provincial Mail on Sunday columnist, Peter Hitchens, which is a shame for some.
However, perhaps I should not be so surprised or angered by our willingness to lead a dual life. The English, after all, are also known for their hypocrisy.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are not representative of Palatinate, and are those of the author only. If you disagree with the opinions expressed, or would like to write for Palatinate in response, please contact the Politics Section at politics@palatinate.org.uk.
Photograph: Newtown grafitti via Flickr
