The Palatine Collection

rsz_artpc_nicolettaasciuto_006
by Oliver Newson

When art enters a functional space, it can never be appreciated as it would in a dedicated gallery. The collection at the Palatine Centre—where Warhols rest on leather sofas and a reception desk interrupts Pomerance’s Sphere of Redemption—does nothing to disprove this assumption. On what can only be described as a paradoxically overlong whistle-stop tour of the Palatine collection, it was disappointing to hear that artwork had been chosen to enhance the space rather than to be admired in its own right.

The university’s policy that art should be ‘seen, not stored’ became blatant as my companion gasped, “Caulfield! Lichtenstein! Is that really Picasso?”, reeling off name after name. Many artists are represented, their work supposedly united by ‘the human condition’.

This creates one main problem: continuity—or lack thereof. How can a tour begin with Peter Sales’ industrial metalwork of local import, aptly overhanging a hard-working barista and his whirring coffee machine, and conclude with some of Sandra Blow’s carefree, colourful abstracts (plainly arranged in size order)? These polar opposites in style and sentiment should not be in the same room, let alone the same collection.

The grid layout of the ‘art wall’ is indicative of a seemingly scientific approach to organisation. Hung personally by Dr Dyson, the curator, the paintings, mostly light-friendly lithographs, are arranged according to hue. The immense, white panel they inhabit could have been exploited to draw attention to particularly pieces; instead, the sheer number of works appears to be an attempt to defeat the imposing empty space.

Not one level of the narrow corridor felt conducive to absorbing art. On the ground floor, our necks strained upwards. Higher up, viewers were separated from the artwork by a physical void (or potentially life-threatening drop).

Venables’ upbeat mural was distorted by the angle of the wall and covered by a bridge, while the veneer reception desk constricted our viewing space. Directly beneath a lonely Picasso dove, an ugly refuge point sign distracted my eye—if only it had been an ironic comment on this being a peaceful area away from the overwhelming ‘art wall’. Besides, a dingy spot near a lift did not do Picasso any favours.

Cry for Freedom: The Hostage, a bronze sculpture by Fenwick Lawson, was the only piece that needed to be away from the intense rays pouring through the glass roof. Depicting a body subjected to torture, situated within the Law Departmentdue to its themes of humn rights, it struck me as insensitive to bathe this vision of a real-life injustice in sunshine.

Abundant colour and a sense of humour certainly injected life into the Palatine Centre. A Turps Banana by Hirst was wryly tucked behind a structural wall. We snatched a peek at some delicately painted, beautifully punctuated pieces in The Anne Galbraith Boardroom, though an impending meeting meant we couldn’t catch the artist’s name. A mélange of little vignettes came together for a Band Aid painting: a jumbled delight.

Tragically crammed into a glass cabinet without any accompanying plaques, a vibrant collection of Benin bronzes provided a much-needed counterpoint to the primary colours of Blow and co. Posters circulated for the 1972 Olympics were a highlight as utilitarian art met working environment. While Calder’s abstracts fitted the airy surroundings, one of his famous mobiles would have offered the perfect focal point.

I applaud the university for wanting to become influential in the art world; however, amongst all the controversy, I couldn’t help thinking that less could have been more—in the collection and during the tour. There is next to no information about the specific works on display either online or in the booklet provided, obliterating any potential educational value to the collection.

Never have I seen a student swivel the Sphere of Redemption, an installation lauded as interactive. As the tour passed through security doors ‘accessibility’ didn’t feel like a priority. Dr Dyson asserted that ‘good art is unfathomable’ and, sadly, the collection is just that: a real pity considering that the artwork itself is deserving of a public admission fee.

Photograph: Nicoletta Ascuito