The Pains of Progress

By Reeya Gadhvana

Born in Stuttgart in 1770, Hegel’s unique logical and philosophical methodology, he believed, bested the apolitical, unemotional and insincerely linear approach to historical inquiry prevalent at the time. While references to Hegel are prolific, and his ideas notorious partly due to his influence upon the historical materialism of Karl Marx, his most fervent supporters often contend he remains commonly misunderstood. These misunderstandings stem partially from the complexity of his explored concepts, but more from the confusing manner in which he wrote which unintentionally obfuscates his main ideas. Nonetheless, Hegel’s uniquely logical, compassionate and moreover optimistic approach to history and political inquiry are a powerful guide in these difficult times.

Hegel’s notion of greatest interest is his idea of the dialectic. Rather than the linear progression of history that most historians and thinkers of his era contended, Hegel instead painted a picture of a slightly more sinuous series of events; and so, for Hegel, history moved forward in a dialectical way. The term ‘dialectic’ is a philosophical term for an argument comprised of three parts; a thesis, an antithesis and a synthesis. The idea is that both the thesis and antithesis contain parts of the truth, but remain exaggerations and distortions of the whole, and so need to clash and interact until their best elements find resolution in a synthesis. In short, the general tendency of progress is not one best explained by a linear leap. 

This was an idea explored in his writings such as The Phenomenology of Spirit 1807, demonstrating that every era can be looked at as a repository of wisdom and further in his lectures on the Philosophy of World History published in 1830. Most of all, as a writer who lived during the indulgent era pre-French Revolution, through to the terror, as well as the emergence of Napoleon’s militaristic brutism in the name of liberty, he saw elements of jagged but nonetheless resolute progress. 

Hence, three things we can learn from Hegel are: 

  1. Important revelations can be found in history 
  2. There is always something to be learned, especially in ideas we dislike
  3. Progress is messy 

While not strictly a political thinker, Hegel’s inquiries seem to be an unmatched bastion of hope, particularly in the current era of political anxiety stemming from the rise of populism, polarization and the exigencies of an increasingly entwined global polity. While historically, equally tumultuous periods have been devastating, they have nonetheless been transient and resulting in refined syntheses over time. Think of liberal constitutional societies following eras of inherited monarchical rule or despotism, or the gradual increase of rights of minorities with the increasing self-awareness of the political establishment. Hence in times that seem bleak indeed, the 19th century philosopher reminds us that societies may have to go through a variety of reversals before advancing; much like a pendulum. This congenital optimism can be deployed in aid of remedying injustices of the existing period in hope of a better future. It is Martin Luther King that wrote that the arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends towards justice; this optimism of progress is in many ways what Hegel contends, although his arc inheres a slightly more circuitous form.

Image: elojeador via flickr