The Orange Book Prize – sexist or essential?

by Ettie Bailey-King
Fame, fortune and eternal life (or something not dissimilar) await the winner of the 2011 Orange Prize for Fiction, for which the nominees were announced in April.
With prize money totalling £30,000, the financial rewards are substantially more than even the prestigious Booker or Whitbread awards, while past winners include some of the most critically-acclaimed and commercially successful writers of their generation.
Yet the chair of this year’s panel looks forward to the days when “the Orange Prize will no longer need to exist”. Why? Because the Orange Prize is for women only.
Since its foundation in 1996, the Orange Prize has suffered both male and female detractors, who regard it as patronising, out-dated, and even sexist. Alain De Botton expressed the crux of the problem when he demanded to know: “What is it about being a woman, that is particularly under threat, in need of attention, or indeed distinctive from being a man, when it comes to picking up a pen?”
In an age in which education and employment are not merely available but positively expected from most women, it is tempting to say that the need for positive discrimination has melted away. Yet anyone who suggests that men and women now compete on an even playing field should think again.
70% of books are written, and purchased, by women. Yet The London Review of Books concentrates 74% of its attention upon male authors, and 78% of its reviews are penned by men. American publications are even less representative, and literary awards the world over tell the same story. The Nobel Prize for Literature has honoured just nine women in 103 years, and the UK’s Whitbread has seen only two female winners in its four-decade history.
In terms of pure proportionality, one has to ask: are women writers really so bad? It would be misogynistic in the extreme to imply that women were, by virtue of gender alone, less talented. In fact, statistics regularly show that women out-perform men at all levels of education and typically score 3 points higher on standardised IQ tests.
Rather the problem is that female literature is pigeonholed as feminine literature: chick lit, concerned with periods, not politics; the petty and the parochial. Paul Bailey, chairman of an all-male ‘shadow jury’ to the Orange Prize in 2001, remarked that the men “didn’t go for books banging on about breast cancer, mothers and daughters – we’ve had all that up to our eyeballs.”
In response to the disproportionate showing of men on the pages of the Times Literary Supplement, editor Peter Stothard spoke of the very different “kind of fiction” written by men and women. For Stothard, and other ‘gatekeepers’ of the literary world, female fiction is not only different but somehow inferior.
If this perception persists, does an all-female book prize simply exacerbate the problem? Booker Prize winner A.S. Byatt has refused any involvement with the Orange Prize, saying it “ghettoizes women”. Yet as a writer who operates under gender-neutral initials rather than her first name, arguably Byatt’s wish to evade categorisation as a ‘woman’ writer is similarly reductive.
Some may argue that a special prize for women has dangerous implications. If the prize suggests that women cannot compete directly against men, or need special help to bring them into the public eye, this is certainly an undesirable side-effect.
Whether it is sexism or positive discrimination that creates or sustains these separate categories – of male writers and female writers – one cannot help but observe that at least these secure a distinguished arena for the books to be examined and – ones hopes – be accorded whatever critical opinion they deserve.
The organizers of the Orange Prize seem squeamish about declaring overtly ‘feminist’ allegiances. In previous years its website has stressed that the only reason there is no comparable prize for men is that nobody has yet “made the effort to set one up”.
It stresses that “in the past”, female writers have not always been assessed fairly, and that its role now is continue its tradition rather than to bring radical change.
Yet one only has to look at the coverage of female nominees for prestigious awards (like Michele Roberts for the Booker; Kate Atkinson for the Whitbread) to remember that the media already does a ferocious job of dissecting female writers’ lives and careers along gendered lines. Surely most of us would be surprised to discover any male nominee being treated as though they were representative of an entire sex.
In its quiet way, one is inclined to agree with the Prize’s founders in observing that paradoxically, the only way to take gender out of the equation is for all the entrants to be women.
