The North to miss out under proposed NHS funding changes

by Anissa Alifandi

NHS

Researchers from Durham University have calculated that possible changes to the allocation formula used by the NHS could result in ‘less healthy’ regions receiving less healthcare funding.

The distribution of NHS spending currently considers the level of social deprivation in a region, substantiating the organisation’s principle of “equal opportunity of access for equal need.”

However, the new formula, proposed by the Advisory Committee on Resource Allocation, would place less emphasis on economic standing, concentrating more on age.

Regions where the average life expectancy is lower- predominantly in the North of England- would therefore receive less funding due to a lower proportion of older citizens.

Professor Bambra and Dr Copeland of the Wolfson Research Institute for Health and Wellbeing investigated the potential outcomes of this new formula.

An affluent South East council in the county of Hampshire would see a 14% healthcare budget increase, whereas the North East city of Sunderland would experience an 11% loss, equating to a £146 decrease in spending per person.

Life expectancy differences are just one example illustrating the North-South divide. The life expectancy of a healthy woman in Sunderland is 58 years old, compared to 68 for a woman in South East Hampshire.

Reasons behind this are often attributed to the industrial decline, but a future threat comes in the form of obesity, with cases being almost twice as high in the most deprived areas than the least.

The “weighted capitation formula” in question affects the money received by Clinical Commissioning Groups. These bodies, made up of GPs within a community, determine how the NHS operates in a given area.

The fate of hospitals, walk-in centres, health visits, rehabilitation and emergency services is dictated by the delegation of resources allotted by these boards.

Despite the on-going review process, the letter detailing the findings was published in the British Medical Journal on October 15th and forewarns healthcare professionals of the damage these changes, if implemented, could cause.

Written by Professor Bambra and Dr Copeland themselves, it argues that such a radical transition would only widen the North-South health inequality gap. Talks currently being held by NHS England evaluating amendments to the policy should conclude by December 2013.

GPs in the North have responded with letters to local MPs expressing concern for the wellbeing of their patients. Bambra and Copeland also believe such changes are a “first step towards an age only allocation.”

Photograph: Emma Werner