“The Neglect was criminal”: Isolating in Hatfield College

By Millicent Machell

I am drawing to the end of a two-week isolation in college accommodation and, as the Coldplay song says, nobody said it was easy but no one ever said it would be this hard. After 12 days with no hoover, no access to a washing machine, two-bread based meals a day and a maximum of 40 minutes outside, I am feeling neglected and used. 

I am not the only one.

Students remarked that they received more support from the NHS track and trace calls than from the college

The results of an informal survey I conducted amongst 52 Hatfield residents are alarming. 71% of the students did not feel the mental health support they received in isolation was sufficient. Participants stated that they felt they were “constantly being told off rather than checked on”, and “the college did nothing, the neglect was criminal”. Several students remarked that they received more support from the NHS track and trace calls than from the college.

The catering was one of the most shocking aspects of my isolation and others seem to agree – only 12.5% of students in the survey felt that the food they were given during isolation was “satisfactory and sufficient”. The daily meal plan includes a pastry and a yogurt for breakfast, the same selection of premade sandwiches for lunch (with or without fruit and crisps, depending on the day) and one hot meal for dinner. Students remarked that the food is of “awful quality’ and ‘extremely unhealthy”.  I am often given the sense that we are being fed in the quickest way possible that meets basic calorific requirements, with very little thought given to the people on the other side of the operation who will be living only on these foods for two weeks. 

As one would expect a college full of young people to understand, poor food choices can be hugely detrimental to students’ mental and physical wellbeing. I was sent several photos that a student has taken of meals she was given in college whilst isolating. She has celiac disease and is vegetarian. These meals are either completely unsatisfactory in nutritional value or do not fill her dietary requirements. Some of them clearly do not contain enough calories to sustain an adult. The student is recovering from an eating disorder and said that the failure to meet her dietary needs has been “a nightmare” and a severe challenge for her mental health. In a time when so many of our students suffer from mental health issues, her case is surely one of many.

Pictures a Hatfield student took of the food she was given that does not fulfil her dietary requirements

Several students described their irregular access to toilet paper

Students also complained about their lack of exercise time and access to cleaning equipment. Currently, the college allots each isolating household 40 minutes of fresh air on the college tennis court which, as several students pointed out, you could easily miss if your contact hours fell at the same time. Furthermore, 83.7% of students said that the “the cleaning materials and opportunities to keep your room sanitary” were not sufficient, remarking on the lack of access to a hoover, washing machine or cleaning products despite their persistent requests. Several students described their irregular access to toilet paper, a factor which worsened the experience from unpleasant to unsanitary. 

As any email correspondence will surely remind you, we are living in “unprecedented times”. However, the college was aware, during the six months of summer holidays this year, that students would be isolating and seem either extremely unprepared or simply indifferent. A lack of preparation is perhaps more forgivable than the lack of reply that myself and multiple other students have received when emailing the college with our requests and complaints. We are, of course, unable to complain in person and therefore unable to do anything else.

“This college is operating only as a business”

More than anything, I find this experience disappointing. Hatfield College harbours some of my best memories. I met best friends here, celebrated birthdays and Christmases and lived away from home for the first time. Returning to live in for my third year seemed a stable choice which would provide me with the mental and physical support I needed to excel in my final year assessments. However, the treatment I have experienced has made me feel as if this college is operating only as a business, rather than somewhere which we have also always been encouraged to see as a place of care and kindness, which fosters our potential as students. 

Even leaving aside any duty of pastoral care that the college may have and reducing the situation to that of any accommodation block, the lack of food, cleanliness and facilities does leave me wondering, as a student exclaimed in the survey, “What am I paying almost 8 and a half grand a year for?”