The Nations Championship: world rugby’s unnecessary cry for attention

By Louis Edward

In 2026, the inaugural Nations Championship will take place as 12 teams from the Northern and Southern hemispheres play each other across the usual July and November windows. The Six Nations teams (England, France, Ireland, Italy, Scotland and Wales) will take on each of the SANZAR nations (Argentina, Australia, New Zealand and South Africa) plus Fiji and Japan across six rounds of matches. The round robin will culminate in a finals weekend hosted at the Allianz Stadium, Twickenham. 

The plans for the tournament, which will be staged every other year henceforth, were approved by World Rugby in 2023 to “align the world calendar.” Six Nations CEO Tom Harrison lauded the new competition: “Rugby’s strongest nations have collaborated with a clear vision to grow the game, […] to create a tournament structure with genuine global relevance, which will unlock the true value of the sport.”  

The Nations Championship has proven commercial appeal, with the broadcasting rights being picked up quickly. The New Zealand versus South Africa tie in September attracted an 80,000 crowd to Twickenham. UEFA’s similar invention of the bi-annual Nation’s League has been a commercial success despite prior criticism of an over-saturated calendar. There is evidence to support World Rugby’s plans and appeal for a final’s weekend in London.  

The Nations Championship has proven commercial appeal, with the broadcasting rights being picked up quickly

But the “grow the game” mantra has been a contentious promise. The phrase was omnipresent in the publicity for the initial plan, and now when selling it to the rugby world. The overhaul of the rugby calendar has come under fire from many of the nations in rugby’s second tier. Samoa international Lima Sopoaga called the tournament a “slap in the face” that “undermines the spirit of inclusivity that rugby is supposed to stand for.”  

The structure of the new tournament means that the top tier of international rugby will be ringfenced for 12 months, with no match-ups against the top teams for the likes of Georgia, Samoa, Uruguay, Romania, Tonga among others who have been promised more exposure for years. A parallel Nations Cup will take place alongside the Nations Championship with 12 nations competing (including the above mentioned) in the same format.

However, no promotion or relegation between the Championship and the Cup will be considered before 2030. Georgia especially have expressed disappointment. They are currently ranked above both Wales and Japan but were passed over for Nations Championship inclusion. 

The aim of the tournament is undoubtedly the finances of the top nations. The competition is focused on the most commercially appealing teams and stadiums. With talk of the 2028 Nations Championship final being played in the Middle East, where rugby is a non-sport, but potential sponsorship revenue is in oversupply, the logic of the tournament is clear. After last year’s bonus scandal in English rugby, where RFU CEO Bill Sweeney took an almost £1-million bonus despite record losses for the union, the decision-making of those at the top of rugby is straying towards a FIFA-esque standard.  

That is not to say that increased revenues aren’t crucial for the expansion of rugby around the world. However, the way the money is raised and distributed has been called into question. Fiji, the poorest of the 12 nations, will play all 7 of their games in 2026 away from home and their home continent.

The aim of the tournament is undoubtedly the finances of the top nations. The competition is focused on the most commercially appealing teams and stadiums

Former England international Anthony Watson called the system a “handout” making the nation “reliant on playing away games”, rather than generating revenue at home. If World Rugby are determined to grow the game commercially in the Pacific Islands, encouraging the top nations on tours there would be a more appropriate long-term strategy.  

Amongst fans, critics have suggested that the Nations Championship will devalue the product that international rugby already has. A rugby “super league” is no doubt detrimental to the status of the quadrennial World Cup, detracting from its unique position as the world-champion-crowning tournament. World Rugby suggest that the extra jeopardy that the Nations Championship gives to the global calendar will boost the international game.

But this autumn alone has seen matches of the highest calibre and jeopardy from non-tournament games. Wales versus Japan was a showstopper that no Welsh fan will forget. Nor will the English forget their triumphant win over the All Blacks. Nor will the Argentinians forget their heroic comeback against Scotland. The international game is not in need of added jeopardy. It has a product built on generations of rivalry – not silverware. Only time will tell if the Nations Championship can deliver on its big promises. 

Image: ezioman via Wikimedia Commons