The myth of just war should end
Mourning for the deceased is among the most natural of human instincts, paying special respect to those fallen in combat the same.
So the British don their blood-red poppies, symbols plucked from the fields of Flanders, and so is there an air of heightened sensitivity when it comes to the mourning of the battle-dead.
This sensitivity now and then rises to the surface, a recent example being the row over FIFA banning the use of the poppy on football shirts.
So too is there a certain amount of friction surrounding even those who refuse – or neglect – to partake in this nationwide process of remembrance. Robert Fisk, renowned political commentator, recently said in The Independent that “those who flaunt the poppy on their lapels […] mock the war dead”.
It is a view motivated by the horrors his father suffered in the First World War combined with the incompetence and disregard for human life that the leaders in that war displayed.
But should the objection over the intentions and capabilities of the military leadership have any amount of bearing over how the dead are mourned? The question is whether such losses are ever necessary.
There is a consensus of sorts that the appalling deaths of the First World War were needless and avoidable and that the leadership of the time was largely at fault for them.
The losses of the Second World War, on the other hand, are generally considered tragic but necessary in the face of the Nazi threat. But the poppy honours the fallen of the past and present. So where do the current conflicts stand?
No-one quite knows what is being fought over in the Middle East- certainly not what the British are fighting for. The usual suspects readily present themselves, with “combating terrorism” normally muscling its way to the front- terrorism, that Lernaean Hydra of a beast whose tail no-one can tell from its myriad heads.
Never mind the fact that Britain had not tasted terror until well after its troops sunk their boots into the sands of Mesopotamia, does anyone truly believe that ransacking Baghdad will lessen the amount of potential terrorists- rather than increase the number of people who have lost everything and are willing to exact crazed revenge in any which way they can? There is, in a sense, no better manufacturer of terrorism than the War on Terror itself.
Another justification is that these wars are to free the natives from their local despots, be they groups or individuals. But just as the British public were not asked whether they were willing to pay with the lives of their children, these families, one day waking up to the sounds of bombs and infants both screaming, were also given no choice. And they, unlike British soldiers, did not even sign their names on any army roll.
But as balm to the bereaved families of servicemen, is there any harm to this rhetoric of self-defense and promulgation of liberty, even if it is through bomber jets? Should not those who have lost their children at least feel that it was for an undeniably just cause?
This seems to be the sombre consensus that overcomes the country when the poppies are clad. But the answer is yes. Yes there is much harm. To both sides, to humanity as a whole.
The longer these losses are explained, rationalised and justified, the more that they will happen. The longer people accept these unexplained wars as necessary, the more good servicemen and women will be lost, and the more terror will be born of the devastation. It is a brutal cycle.
Yes, children lost in war should be mourned by mother and motherland, and honoured too- but in defiance of the leadership that sent them out to be killed, not hand-in-hand with it.
The longer we keep convincing ourselves that their deaths were necessary, the longer we keep the spirit of the Great War alive: that serpent which whispers words of glory, honour and freedom into our ears whilst blinding us with its venom from the needless destruction that those empty words leave in their wake.
That old lie told to children ardent for some desperate glory is more alive than we would ever like to imagine, and is now being murmured to mourning mothers too.

