The MUDS’ Manifesto
By Alfie Whillis
Belying the impression of an active function band scene in Durham is a slowly creeping trend of exploitation. At a growing number of events, musicians are expected to perform for measly wages, often late at night and outside of Durham. Even when pay is fair, they can face a lack of clarity from organisers concerning set times and secure instrumental storage, no transport from the venue at a reasonable time, and poor tech provision.
The Musicians’ Union of Durham Students (MUDS) emerged from egregious issues regarding the 2018 June Ball. Musicians were outraged by the fact that JB2018 was not only “pay-to-stay” but it was “pay-to-play”; there was no option for payment other than a small discount off an expensive ents ticket. Though due to JB’s financial difficulties they failed to escape an ents-only deal, MUDS successfully negotiated a better payment plan and were armed with promises of fair pay in future.
This week, MUDS’ manifesto was released.
Predictably, this confrontation of overambitious event organisers and impassioned musicians boiled over again when June Ball 2019 made an offer seen as paltry by student musicians. There was frequently aired dissatisfaction with the perceived implication that performing at JB was an honour in itself, though it remains unclear if any statement was ever made to that effect by a member of the JB committee. An open letter was quickly drawn up by MUDS and soon reached over 350 signatories, forcing the JB exec to negotiate. Last year the committee told Palatinate that “in hindsight, we should have probably asked performers for a quote before making them an offer, to check whether we could afford to meet their expectations.”
Having resorted to collective bargaining twice, many musicians realised that, without systemic change, exploitation likely would continue. At the end of 2018/19, MUDS was constituted as an independent society, separate from DSU and Music Durham. Its newly elected committee started drafting a manifesto outlining their expectations from event organisers. This week, the manifesto was released.
The manifesto even stretches to musicians’ behaviour, detailing that ‘Musicians should not be visibly intoxicated on stage’, for example.
The President of MUDS, Matt Bartlett, summed up the manifesto as a ‘comprehensive guide for everything to do with booking musicians’. Although MUDS repeatedly stress that their manifesto consists of guidelines, not rules, Bartlett still emphasises plans ‘to try and get it ratified and stuck to by as many colleges as possible’. The cause of this apparent contradiction is perhaps that they view their guidelines as minimum expected standards rather than proposing fair minimum wages, such as £200 per hour for a band or £50 per hour for a singer.
To some this might sound like very generous pay, but Bartlett justifies MUDS’ recommendations: ‘If you take into account personal practice time alone it becomes a lot more than just a one-hour set. Additionally, musicians invest significant amounts of money into lessons, instruments and tech that we probably never make back’. Other guidelines include the provision of a secure green room and stipulating that at charity events musicians may ‘receive their full fee or choose to donate any amount of it back to charity’. The manifesto even stretches to musicians’ behaviour, detailing that ‘Musicians should not be visibly intoxicated on stage’, for example.
MUDS’ ultimate aim is ambitious: a total shift in organisers’ expectations and values. As their manifesto states, MUDS wants to ‘develop a culture where paying musicians is seen as a necessary overhead, just like hiring a venue’. Bartlett explains: ‘You’d be hard-pressed to find an external service (such as tech) that would compromise on pay.’ Though the response from event organisers remains to be seen, it’s clear that when the 2020 June Ball rolls around, expectations from musicians will be high.
Image: Alex Ashton
