The Morality of Bombs: Illegal Warfare or Pragmatic Necessity?
By Will Parsons
Just after 2.00am on October 3rd, medical staff in Medicine Sans Frontieres’ hospital in Kunduz, Afghanistan, made desperate attempts to contact military headquarters in both Kabul and Washington DC. The hospital was being bombarded by a US gunship which targeted the main building repeatedly. Medical workers’ eventual life line – a text from one Nato officer forty-five minutes in – did not herald the end of the attack. Despite contact being made, twenty-two people had lost their lives when it finally ended after more than an hour. Ten patients and twelve staff were killed.
The hospital building had been targeted specifically: outlying buildings were spared. Despite attempts at contact, despite the precision of the aircraft involved, and despite MSF reportedly communicating the location of the hospital to military officials four days prior, Coalition forces nevertheless undertook precision airstrikes against the building. Somewhere along the line, a miscommunication or blunder brought about the deaths of these people and the violation of international law.
The implications this tragedy has for bombing campaigns in general are critical. At a time when such campaigns are being floated as something of a ‘cure-all’ for the situation in Syria, and when official UK involvement in the region is still open to debate, it’s about time the viability of strategic bombing is seriously questioned.
Weapons technology has come a long way since the ‘daisy cutters’ of Vietnam and the cluster bombs of the Gulf War, but for all the precision that goes with these advances, civilians are still caught up – their deaths remorselessly labelled ‘collateral damage’. At least 225 Syrian civilians have been killed by coalition airstrikes thus far. Russian airstrikes are said to have caused over 375 casualties, many of them civilians. Russians have targeted urban areas, with some claiming that hospitals have been hit.
With the horrific attacks in Paris, we can probably expect more bombing campaigns – and more deaths – in retaliation, but if we look at the historical precedent of such revenge attacks, it becomes clear that these actions could do more harm than good. In the wake of 9/11, the US conducted extensive bombing raids on Afghanistan as ‘retaliation’ for the attack. As many as 20,000 civilians died in 2001 as a result of starvation and illness brought about by the bombing, and at least 3,100 were directly killed. The bombing did not subdue conflict; it in fact enflamed the civil war as the Taliban increased its actions and the raids cut Afghanistan off from vital international aid. Bombing in Afghanistan did much more harm than good; in killing some of its ‘enemies’, the US created many more.
Drone strikes, also, need to be given more serious consideration. A year ago it was reported that although forty-one men had been targeted by US drones in Pakistan and Afghanistan, 1,147 people were killed. In the case of Baitullah Mehsud, seven drone strikes were needed to eventually kill him, leaving 164 others dead. For all the precision offered by drones, they still fail to safely achieve objectives. The world will not be a more peaceful place so long as innocents are killed or forced to flee in vast numbers. If anything, indiscriminate bombing raids and haphazard drone strikes will build antagonisms by creating a climate of fear and destroying homes.
So what’s the solution? If the tragedy in Kunduz tells us anything, it’s that there needs to be better communication both with and within Nato command. Civilian and non-governmental institutions like MSF hospitals need a guaranteed direct line of communication in emergencies such as this. Not that such emergencies should occur in the first place; if MSF did indeed notify Nato of its location then clearly some communication breakdown took place in Nato command. Measures should be taken to ensure that all relevant information is carefully considered before any bombing raids or drone strikes take place: maybe in this way, Nato and others can avoid carnage similar to that done in Afghanistan.
The persistent truth, however, is that despite the increased precision of weapons, moral ambiguity will always remain. How justified is it to take someone’s life without a fair trial to prove their guilt? Some of the evidence used to inform attacks on high profile figures in Afghanistan and Pakistan is obtained through torture, an inherently unreliable and disgracefully immoral source. By using a drone strike or air raid to kill specific targets, we are automatically passing moral judgement on the victim based on our own moral ideals or on the victim’s supposed role as a threat to our society. How can we be certain that our evidence unequivocally proves their guilt? Can we be sure that later evidence won’t prove their innocence? These questions in part led to the abolition of the death penalty in our own country, yet it seems acceptable to forego these reservations when ruling over the lives of people outside our borders.
Maybe bombs are a necessary evil in combating ISIS. Nevertheless, I would urge utmost caution. Sweeping bombing campaigns might seem like the answer, but they would only create horror in response to horror. Bombs could reduce ISIS’ military capabilities, but they could also take many lives of those innocents the West claims to protect: ISIS is a greater threat to the people of Syria and Iraq than it is to the French or to any Europeans. The lives of innocents, of ‘collateral damage’, must take precedence in debates over the viability of bombing campaigns, not only due to moral considerations, but because – as in Afghanistan – they might well prove to be a step back and not a step forward.
Photograph: Greg Goebel via Flickr
