The moral submissiveness of Roman Polanski's defenders
Entertainment scandal is always a source of in-depth coverage, so Palatinate readers may already be well aware of the story surrounding Roman Polanski, who is currently being held in Zurich, and facing extradition to the US for child molestation charges which he admitted committing back in the late seventies.
The French-born director, famous for films such as Rosemary’s Baby and The Pianist is accused of the rape of a thirteen year old girl and has been on the run from the law ever since release from the Californian authorities. Due to their weaker extradition policies, he has been living in France and Poland and avoiding all countries where he may face arrest. He was arrested by Swiss authorities whilst trying to enter the country last month.
The response to this by the public and the media has been quite peculiar to say the least. To give just two examples: as it currently stands, over a hundred people from the film industry have signed a petition for his immediate release from custody, and politicians from both France and Poland have criticised the arrest.
Comments made by public figures reached their zenith of stupidity when French Minister of Culture and Communication Frédéric Mitterrand uttered “the sight of him thrown to the lions for an old story which doesn’t make much sense, imprisoned while travelling to an event that was intending to honour him: caught, in short, in a trap, is absolutely dreadful”. He then added, presumably with a straight face, that Polanski “had a difficult life” but had “always said how much he loves France, and he is a wonderful man”.
Two main arguments in favour of Polanski’s release, both epitomised in Mitterand’s nonsense statement, seem to form the backdrop for those wishing for his release. Both show the person making the argument to have little to no understanding of the way the law or our society works.
Firstly, let us deal with the argument presented in the media, the suggestion that as the alleged crime is said to have been committed a long time ago it is somehow of relevance to the case – the “it all happened such a long time ago” argument if you will. We have seen this point being repeated ad nauseam, usually in an apologetic tone as if this is a sublimely wise and noble position to take.
For anyone who knows the least thing about law, there is no time limit threshold, short of the pursued fugitive’s death, when a person who has charges against them is suddenly considered to be free from facing court and having those charges considered and tried.
Thankfully, the policy of law and law enforcement officials is to pursue fugitives for as long as the charges remain outstanding; and through all legal and available means. If this was not the case we would never have seen war criminals such as Adolf Eichman, architect of the Holocaust who went into hiding in South America for over 10 years, face justice for the death and misery he caused.
Are those who claim that the staleness of Polanski’s alleged crimes is reason for his release willing to follow their logic all the way through? I think and hope not. (As a side note, we may point out that in terms of personal morality, surely the fact that someone has evaded justice for so long should make us want him or her to face the consequences of their actions all the more.)
The second argument given in favour of Polanski’s release is the evoking of his achievements and talents as a director and artist. Naturally, this is often done in vague and ethereal tones such as those by the French minister, attempting to gloss over the sinister premises behind the argument. There are some hidden conclusions or insinuations in this argument that remain unsaid, but are baffling once exposed.
One of the following should sum up the gist of what is being implied; that these achievements somehow make him exempt from the law and that he should no longer be pursued, or even worse, that he must by definition be innocent and need not be tried.
Again, those who make such an argument show themselves to be foolishly ignorant of one important fundamental of the law: that the law judges actions, not people, and that personal achievements do not put anyone under a separate consideration of any kind. Household names cannot be treated any differently if our society is to be considered fair.
This argument also shows a childish handling of logic – by using his achievements to insinuate that he should not be tried, they are committing what is known as the ‘irrelevant thesis fallacy’ – where irrelevant information is used to distort or lie.
And if people such as Mitterand are claiming talented people must by definition be innocent (only he knows what nonsense he was really insinuating) then why not let Polanski prove this by facing trial and clearing his name?
Of course, we must mention that there may be issues regarding a person’s circumstances that are worthy of consideration. We have seen a thoughtful and well meaning debate arise concerning the fate of Gary McKinnon who faces extradition to the United States on charges of hacking into the systems of the Pentagon and CIA. The fact that McKinnon suffers from Asperger’s Syndrome, a form of autism, is certainly a consideration that may be valid in this case, perhaps also that he was hacking into the systems in an attempt to find evidence of alien life.
But surely in cases of personal achievement or talent this cannot be a serious consideration. Again, follow this argument to its natural conclusions and we see why it is so far outside what the law accepts – does the fact that Harold Shipman was a doctor, and hence was certainly intelligent and probably helped as well as harmed many, excuse his actions of murder? We could all come up with many more examples of this logic in action which show the absurdity of applying it to criminal cases.
This form of pseudo-argument was displayed similarly at the 2003-2005 child molestation trial of the late Michael Jackson. Perhaps we will never know whether he was guilty of the alleged crimes, but either way who can forget the people who were hollering from the rafters about what a great singer and cultural icon he was – of course omitting the obvious insinuations that this somehow excused child abuse, that he deserved not to be tried as a result or that these facts must proclaim his innocence.
Many pages could be devoted to the aspects of law that render these arguments hopeless, but apart from displaying a laughable ignorance of the law, those who wish for Polanski not to face trial are also displaying a wholly repugnant moral submissiveness. Perhaps they should be reminded of the details of this case: Polanski is accused of not just having sex with a minor. According to the charges and the victim’s account he boozed her up on champagne, drugged her and then raped her, not just in the statutory sense as many suggest, but fully against her will.
These are very serious offences which cannot be accepted in a society that for a second calls itself civilised. Who of us with female relatives of this age can think of them being subjected to this treatment by a 44-year-old man – who had all the while been put in a position of trust by having her over for what was arranged as a harmless photo shoot – without feeling our blood curdle in disgust?
Certainly statutory rape is a contentious moral and legal issue. This issue was debated in a serious and civil manner on Radio 4 earlier this year when the boyfriend of a fourteen year-old girl was convicted of statutory rape. The case was made more controversial still by the fact that the mother of the girl knew that a sexual relationship was going on. The mother said that she would have preferred for it to happen at the house than elsewhere and was both praised and scorned in the media.
The case raised many moral and legal issues and debate regarding the age of consent still remains unsettled – the age of consent varies widely across Europe and the world and defying it holds varying penalties.
In Spain the age of consent is currently thirteen – the boyfriend of this fourteen year-old girl would have been in the clear had their sexual relations taken place in that country rather than in Britain. Whether you agree with their laws more than our own or not – and it seems that the debate on the age on consent will continue for years to come – it is not true for a second that Polanski would have been innocent had he committed these alleged acts in Spain. Above all, don’t believe those who pretend that statutory rape is all that has been alleged to have taken place.
Had the charges been that Polanski had sex with a thirteen year-old who had consented to sex, then maybe – and I stress maybe – some of the permissiveness would be justified. But it cannot be ignored that what is said to have happened was the boozing and doping up, attack and rape of another person.
Even if the person had been above the age of consent, this would still be a terrible crime. The girl’s age and her vulnerability only makes it more imperative that this man should be brought to justice. His talent as an artist has no bearing on his innocence or guilt in this case; it is time that the public, and public figures, realised it.
