The masculinity crisis

masculinity

By Ellie Mullan

Feminism is a term that, due to recent proclamations such as Emma Watson’s HeforShe campaign and Beyonce’s neon sign at the VMAs, has been in the public light ever since Emily Davison first stepped out in front of that King’s horse.

However, something that has not been so publicly discussed but has grown in popular debate in response to this media coverage is masculinism – the study of the rights of men.

Many people when faced with the term would instantly swat away the debate due to the fact that men frankly have it better: from substantially better wages, with a recent study from the White House showing that women still earn only 77 per cent of what their male counterparts do despite the Equal Pay Act 1995, to better access to top tier jobs – the advantages of being born a male are sadly endless.

However, following studies from the likes of Richard Collier, it becomes clear that masculinism is something that needs to be at the forefront of discussion. Firstly and perhaps more obviously, in order to inform feminist thought one must understand the masculine perspective also. Collier argues that in order to decipher why these intensely masculine institutions that allow female subordination are in place, we must first look at the study of masculinity.

The second and arguably more important reason for the study of masculinity is its influence in the so-called ‘male crisis’. This crisis of masculinity has become an issue in recent years following a study from CALM (the Campaign Against Living Miserably) which shows that the modern man is struggling to deal with the pressures in both their professional and personal lives. This crisis is held to be in direct relation to the suicide rates of males being at a fifteen-year high, with males accounting for 78 per cent of all suicides in the UK. The report from CALM found that roughly half of the 1,000 surveyed had felt depressive thoughts. If this wasn’t worrying enough, it was found that considerably more women would confide in a friend over these thoughts, whereas 67 per cent of males had not spoken to anyone.

Collier argues that the ideal of gendered autonomy may not fit the aspects of dominant political and cultural ideas that make up men’s practices.

In short, the typical ideal of a heterosexual, rational and strong man does not fit the realities of the modern male, and it is this failure to fit this epitome of manhood that leads to the crisis that has subsumed.

Not only this, but due to the obviously necessary developments in women’s rights, many academics argue that males are undertaking a crisis in confidence in relation to their place in society. Rightly, males are no longer the sole breadwinners or providers to their families, with three-quarters of women questioned from The Telegraph’s survey stating that these terms have now become completely redundant in the 21st century. Although it is obviously necessary that these changes have occurred, we must look at the psychologically detrimental effects this is having on the modern male.

In light of the crisis that has begun, in order to create a homogenous society for both genders, feminism and masculinsm should work together, rather than in opposition, to redirect ideas of gender stereotypes.

Photograph: Eugen Sandow and Wellcome Images via Wellcome Library, London