The Marvel machine
By Niamh Kelliher
Set the scene – its 2008 and, not for the first time, a comic book movie adaptation has hit the cinemas. Audiences walked in expecting the camp of Mick Schumacher or the gritty realism of Christopher Nolan, but instead Marvel Studios’ Iron Man upended the superhero movie entirely by neither removing outlandishness in favour of ‘real cinema’ nor leaning into it. Instead, Marvel took the radical position of taking comic books themselves seriously. It was a star and brand-making project, blending humour and a compelling lead and allowed for the first true example of long-form, serialised storytelling in cinema to begin.
Marvel altered the landscape of blockbuster entertainment, dominated the box office, and changed audience expectations of what the big screen experience could be. They could seemingly do no wrong. Sure, there were entries that had a less than glowing reception (Avengers: Age of Ultron, Thor: The Dark World), but there was such momentum in Marvel’s narrative and popularity that any flaws were shrugged off, quickly forgotten by the next instalment.
Avengers: Endgame arrived in full force in 2019 – Marvel was operating at the height of both its artistic and commercial success, closing out over a decade of storytelling and hype with a spectacular bang. Audiences and critics were largely positive, Oscar nominations came for Endgame and Black Panther, and many of the big-name actors said goodbye on a high. Plans were released for the follow-up, the new phase, the projects that were going to capitalise off of the hype. And it is here that the franchise machine began to break down…
Fans and critics alike have been searching for where Marvel went wrong, and it seems increasingly obvious that quantity is being prioritised over quality
Marvel was one of the first instances of episodic cinema, but with phase four this show seems to be filled with an endless stream of filler episodes. Fans have been stuck with narrative wheel-spin for nearly three years now and every project that seems like it will finally pick up momentum (Doctor Strange: Multiverse of Madness, Ant Man: Quantomania), turns out to be just more table-setting. Fan’s support of this cinematic universe is crumbling as the introduction of new characters becomes exponential, and the actual content feels like something to just bear through for a tease of the next one. Ultimately, a hype machine with no narrative payoff, endless new characters, and no overall journey in sight is not sustainable, and Disney has itself to blame.
Fans and critics alike have been searching for where Marvel went wrong, and it seems increasingly obvious that quantity is being prioritised over quality. The reasons for this are business as much as creatively related. In late 2019, right off the heels of Endgame’s success, Disney became one of the many studios to enter the streaming wars as network and cinema viewership dwindled. With their launch of Disney+ they demanded that the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) transfer into TV, with the hope that the Marvel fan base would transfer with it. With every studio in Hollywood trying to cut through this age of endless content by turning every Intellectual Property they own into an adaptation, reboot, or sequel, this was an understandable strategy. Disney may have entered the streaming wars relatively late, but their wealth of beloved brands gave them an advantage over competitors like Netflix who had only original content to bring in eyeballs. However, by catering to the current ‘attention economy’ Disney has forced Marvel to produce a whopping 15 projects in less than 4 years, and the quality has hugely suffered.
Shows keep attempting to tackle huge topics – racism, the immigrant experience, sexism – but Marvel simply doesn’t allow for more than a surface level exploration before the character needs to throw punches
Out of the gate – Wandavision, Loki and even The Falcon and the Winter Soldier were positively received, but as the care and budget put into the projects reduced so has the reception. Some of the Disney+ shows were victim to the toxic misogyny and racism despite being liked by critics and general audiences (She-Hulk and Ms Marvel) but most of these shows have the same issue: a lack of substance. The writers have been largely blamed for this, not unfairly, but it’s also a nearly impossible task to create a self-contained origin story/character arc alongside an action-packed plot which still works as a PG crowd pleaser, all in just 6 episodes.
The writers cannot deviate from the Marvel ‘formula’, but without the epic VFX and plot lines that are supposed to be saved for the films it’s an uphill battle. And the films aren’t even using all this runway being built! Thor: Love &Thunder, Multiverse of Madness, and Quantomania are not must-see culminations but middling, stale features that depend on the post-credits to justify their relevance. Because of the pace of output, characters’ sequels are being written before their previous project has finished filming, leading to a lack of character continuity and no plot to build off.
Going forward, Marvel needs to decrease its output to prevent this endless treading of water where we’re still in the first act of the overall story nearly 4 years in. The TV shows should serve as character pieces to flesh out lesser-explored characters, and as supporting stories if big events are saved for the films. To do that, there should be less shows and more episodes so that writers can really delve into character psychology while keeping the required, low-stakes action plot that’s enjoyable but pointless. Wandavision has been the best show because of its execution of this, telling a truly emotional story of grief, which actually received criticism upon its return to the cinematic formula in the latter part of the season. The other shows attempted to tackle huge topics – racism, the immigrant experience, sexism – but the Marvel box simply doesn’t allow for more than a surface level exploration before the character needs to throw punches with the bland villain who has the exact same powers as them.
Ultimately Marvel needs to give fans and creatives a better paced story before the franchise machine peters out entirely. Audiences need to be invested in the characters and stories again. We should be excited to see the next step in the story every six months instead of being fed an endless stream of poorly formed copies. A recalibration is sorely needed, or there will be no one lining up for anything Marvel puts out.
Image: Erik Mclean via Unsplash

